Need advice on two stones

[DavTN]

Hey all, I think I am going for an internet stone and a ring from a local jeweler.

1st:
1.12C G SI1 Table 55% Depth 61.5% GIA cert.
6.71-6.75*4.14
$5250

2nd:
1.16C H SI1 Table 56% Depth 62.5% EGL cert.
6.72*6.69*4.19
$5830

How good do you think the cut will be on these stones and is the price good?
Thanks,
DavTN

 

[Richard Sherwood]

The two stones are similar in proportions, but the GIA stone is better color, more reliably graded, and cheaper (not too mention looking slightly better on paper for cut).

For a more accurate assessment, you need to find out with the crown height and pavilion depth is (and/or crown and pavilion angles).

Rich, GG
Sarasota Gemological Laboratory