Nebie help..Which one will look more pretty by naked eye ...

[matrix]

Hi,

They are about same price.
Which one will look more pretty by naked eye and better value?
Which one you would buy? I always want to get Pol: ex Sym: ex but does it look any difference if i pick Pol: ex Sym: vg
?

GIA cert
F color
SI1
Round
Depth: 62%
Table: 58%
Pol: EX
Sym: VG
6.40 X 6.44 X 3.98

GIA cert
H color
VS2
Round
Depth: 60.2%
Table: 58%
Pol: EX
Sym: EX
6.44 x 6.49 x 3.89

 

[Mara]

You really need more info to be able to tell which will look pretty....do you have crown and pavilion angles? Have you seen either stone in person? What are the carat sizes?

The first stone will look like a .95c or similar stone while the second will be closer to 1c. Are they supposed to both be 1ctw? If so, the second definitely looks like it has more potential, esp due to the fact that the depth of the first stone is a little steep at 62%. But it does not rule it out. Try to get more numbers, then you will know more.

Good luck!