shape
carat
color
clarity

Narrowing search for Princess

Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.

UncleG

Rough_Rock
Joined
Jan 14, 2010
Messages
1
I am teaching English in Paris for the school year and my SO of three years is visiting in February for two weeks. I believe I have found a reasonably non-cliché place.

I have enjoyed reading these forums this morning and I am glad to find such a friendly community of diamond enthusiasts. I''d like to post a couple questions that fall into the gray area and see what the experts think
2.gif


Based on my budget, about $3500-$4500, and readings over the last weeks I am looking at the following guidelines.

My best source for a stone/setting is online. I trust the company, use them for other things, even offers an upgrade program, but I am shopping sight unseen.

I plan to set a princess stone in a size 5.5 white gold channel setting, based on her tastes and I''d like to get a stone in the .8 to 1ctw region with no glaring defects to the naked eye.

I am looking at five different stones and I would greatly appreciate your comments,

1. 0.96ctw, J, VVS1, very good cut, table73/depth73, excellent polish/symmetry, slightly thick girdle, *medium florescence*

2. 0.94ctw, J, VS2, excellent cut, table68/depth74.4, very good polish/symmetry, thin to slightly thick girdle

3. 0.88ctw, I, VS2, excellent cut, table67/depth75, very good polish/symmetry, thin to thick girdle, faint florescence

4. 0.87ctw, I, VVS2, very good cut, 71table/75depth, excellent polish, very good symmetry, medium to slightly thick girdle

5. 0.84ctw, H, VS2, excellent cut, table67/depth71, excellent polish, very good symmetry, medium girdle.

I see the pros/sacrifices in each stone, but I don''t know which are negligible to a layman like myself.

Can I rule out a prince stone which table = depth?
Is J a noticeable difference from H?

Sorry if this was a little lengthy. I appreciate it if you read this far!
 
No way to tell the cut performance without images, preferably ASET image.
 
Can''t judge Princess cuts on the numbers.

If you are buying sight unseen then I would stick with AGS graded diamonds because they have actually developed a cut quality grading system whereas other labs have not for princess cuts. An AGSO princess is your best bet for getting a good performer when buying sight unseen and without the aid of pictures and other images.
 
Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top