Narrowed down to this diamond -- opinions?

[FireBrilliance]

I am looking for a engagement ring diamond and I have narrowed to a GIA graded diamond with the following attributes:

Round
7.13 - 7.17 x 4.36 mm
Carat weight: 1.35 carat
Clarity grade: G
Clarity: VS1 (a cloud, crystal, and needle at the edge of the table looking down at the diamond)
Cut grade: Excellent
Polish: Excellent
Symmetry: Excellent
Fluorescence: None

Pavilion angle: 40.8
Pavilion halves length: 75%
Crown angle: 33.5
Table size: 56%
Star length: 45%
Depth: 61%
girdle: Medium-slightly think (faceted)

Based on these numbers, is this diamond good? Comments? Your help is much appreciated! Thanks!

 

[kathness]

I'm not an expert but HCA is scoring it as 2.4

If you have an ideal scope image and picture of the stone this will help the experts provide you a better assessment

 

[FireBrilliance]

I'm not an expert but HCA is scoring it as 2.4

Thank you for your feedback.

Hmm... If I used the HCA tool correctly, I got a score of 0.9. How did you get 2.4?

 

[hawk25]

I'm getting 0.8 on HCA . The numbers look good, but its hard to comment any further without an idealscope. Is it possible to get one?

 

[FireBrilliance]

I'm getting 0.8 on HCA . The numbers look good, but its hard to comment any further without an idealscope. Is it possible to get one?

Thank you. Unfortunately this is a stone from Bluenile, and I am not able to get any of these optical analyses done...

 

[diamondloveaffair]

Then that's basically all you the data you can extract from the stone by going blind. Without images, it is a fruitless exercise to give meaningful opinions which you can already assess by yourself.

 

[kathness]

i must have plugged the numbers incorrectly! sorry op!