shape
carat
color
clarity

Mara/Griff/CutNut/Val...everyone can you please help...

Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
Hehehe I actually have to say I was completely creeped out by the Vatche 'throne' thing...god complex anyone?
rolleyes.gif





Personally I can't see paying a premium for any brand name that is that high...hence why instead of getting a Michael B setting, we had something similar made with almost double the ctw of stones for $400 less than the cheapest MB quote I got. My platinum ring is very well made and we were really happy with the quality of work. I'm a huge custom fan and would go custom every time if it meant that I didn't have to pay exhorbitant markups for someone's reproduced design.




It's along the same lines as something like software. I understand that to create something like a ring could be considered a piece of art, and the markup for the designer actually doing the work himself may make sense, just like when you put thousands of hours of work into creating and perfecting a software package. but once there's a template model for future production AND a team in place to assist with that production, I don't think prices should be higher for the same thing to be made over and over. I don't agree with paying Adobe $2k for a software suite...I'd rather get it on eBay.
2.gif
Luckily I have a friend at Adobe and I can get a legit copy straight from the manuf. for $75...but I digress.
2.gif





I'd pay more for a custom job that only I or a few others had...but not the same price for the same ring that thousands of other people have. My take on it.
2.gif
 


----------------
On 3/12/2004 8:52:58 AM fire&ice wrote:












Vatche is a bird in the hand *known* product. I would be willing to pay a premium for that. That said, I don't think I would pay the keystone price Vatche is demanding these days. That truffle setting is *way* overpriced for what it is.



----------------

F&I, yes you have a point, and if it were more reasonably priced, I probably would buy it. However as you point out, the truffle setting is indeed way overpriced. My original statements may have been stronger than intended, but I was still suffering from sticker shock at the time.



I contacted Martin Fuller to discuss having the stones I am going to buy appraised. He recommended Quest. I did a search here and found positive feedback. I contacted them and asked about their services. They seemed reasonable. Given Martin's reputation here and the feedback on Quest, I going with them. Expect the cost to be significantly less than Vatche.
 
Status
Not open for further replies. Please create a new topic or request for this thread to be opened.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top