Looking for new stone, need advice

[missdiamondy]

Hi, brand new here and I'd love some advice. We are trading in my original engagement ring and upgrading to new stone. I have found two I am interested in, I'd love some input as to which I should choose, if any. Both are 1.9, Ideal cut and excellent polish and symmetry. No cutlets or fluorescence.
stone 1 1.9 color F clarity -VS2 depth 61.3 table 58 crown 34.5 pavillion 40.8 HCA 1.3 7.94 x 7.96 x 4.87
stone 2 1.9 color G clarity VS1 depth 60.5 table 58 crown 34 pavillion 40.6 HCA .7 7.99 x 8.01 x 4.84

I really have learned that picking a diamond is a lot more than the four C's!

 

[Kim N]

Can you put them on hold and post the report numbers?

 

[missdiamondy]

Can you put them on hold and post the report numbers?

Okay I think these are the report numbers. 7453311542 and 744282677
I hope that helps!

 

[Kim N]

Okay I think these are the report numbers. 7453311542 and 744282677
I hope that helps!

I couldn't find the videos from the report numbers. Do you have links to magnified vendor videos? Or even better, can you request ASET images from the vendor?

 

[missdiamondy]

Ah I don't. This is all i have to go on.

 

[Kim N]

Ah I don't. This is all i have to go on.

You can buy an ASET scope to evaluate the diamonds for yourself. Both diamonds look promising from the proportions, but we'd need a video or Ideal-Scope/ASET image to advise further. Without knowing their performance, I have a slight preference for the F.

ASET Scope

datlas.com

 

[missdiamondy]

Thank you so much for taking the time to respond! I will look into getting the ideal scope.

 

[momofive]

I got my ASET scope here. https://www.pricescope.com/tools/aset-scope
They have IDEAL scopes as well. I also ended up buying a diamond pic (the pick up tool) and a diamond ring holder on amazon so I could more the diamond around without getting fingerprints all over it and I could try it on my finger and flash it around in different lights.

 

[missdiamondy]

I got my ASET scope here. https://www.pricescope.com/tools/aset-scope
They have IDEAL scopes as well. I also ended up buying a diamond pic (the pick up tool) and a diamond ring holder on amazon so I could more the diamond around without getting fingerprints all over it and I could try it on my finger and flash it around in different lights.

Great thank you!