shape
carat
color
clarity

Just got IdealScope images back.

cjclark

Rough_Rock
Joined
Aug 18, 2013
Messages
8
Hi everyone,

Just got IS images back JA.com with all three shown attached. I am about to bite the bullet and purchase the stone on the left.

All Diamonds are GIA Excellent / F / VS1.. Gemologist has come back and said the following:

"They all have an excellent amount of brilliance (white light return), with a great amount of fire (dispersion of color) and sparkle that is well balanced and symmetrical. The 0.82 carat was her personal favorite because it is a “spready” stone, making it appear the largest. All three diamonds are a bright, icy white color and face up completely "eye clean". "

The favorite stone mentioned is the very first image on the left, and the IS image looks to back this up.

Any glaring ommissions or inconsistencies that strike anyone looking at the image? As much as I have a lot of faith in the service from JA, they of course have a vested interest in the matter :)

This forum has been so helpful so far, so I value the opinions here!

compare_2.jpg
 
Anyone?
 
Currently stone 1 looks the best, but there are just the idealscope images. Is it possible to get the hearts and arrow and aset images as well ? Also, not sure if I'm correct, but stone 2 looks tilted to me.
 
These were the only images I was able to get back in the time-frame necessary.

I agree re: stone 2, but regardless - to my eye - looks as though stone 1 would still take it.

I am otherwise happy to make a decision (based on price, proportions, dealer, service etc) within the stones presented here, was just wanting to run these particular images across the forum posters here to make sure I wasn't missing something obvious from the Ideal Scope images.

Thanks for your reply!
 
I agree with the gemologist that stone 1 looks the best as far as the ideal scope. Since you're not able to see it in person, I'd go with her opinion...
 
Number 1 definitely looks best.
 
From these images, I would definitely choose stone number 1.
 
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Top