Is this is good deal for a yellow diamond

[fancycolordiamondluver]

HI everyone wondering if this is a good deal for a fancy yellow?

cushion
10.04x9.39x6.54
5.53 cts
depth: 69.6%
table: 68%
girdle: thick to very thick
polish: good
sym: good
clarity vs 2
color: natural fancy yellow
flourescene: faint
Crown angles are greater than 40 degrees

$41,500

thinking about either that one or this one:

radiant
IF
5.26 cts
fancy yellow
girdle: med-very thick
polish: good
sym:good
floures: none

$52,600

 

[belle]

fancies are priced according to the intensity of their coloring, so there is just no way to tell how close these are without actually seeing the stones to determine the depth of color.
i would be leary of a stone with the notation of ''crown angles are greater than 40 degrees''

 

[The Joker]

IMHO:
Color is the most important "C" to consider with fancy colored diamonds.
Colored diamonds are cut to maximize the color, so I would not worry about the > 40* comment as much as if it were a colorless diamond.
Hopefully they both have GIA GTL color reports.
You must see the diamonds.
The first diamond seems to be a good price and the second one seems normal.

 

[widget]

Do you have pictures of these stones?...it would be fun to see them.

You didn''t mention it, but I presume these stones come with GIA reports...I wouldn''t even consider a purchase like this without one.

widget