Indentations on ring from B2C - should I return it?

[diamondquestion1]

I bought a ring from B2cjewels.com and it arrived over the weekend. 0.75 carats H SI1, GIA Ex Ex Ex, Strong blue fluoresence and had it set in a 14K white gold pave cathedral setting.

I really like the stone. My only concern is with the ring. There seem to be some scratches/indentations on it below the rhodium coating (it is shiny over the indentations).

I contacted B2C and they are willing to take the ring back and either repair it or send me a new one, but I wanted to see what you guys thought the reason it looks like this is. I figure I'll have them send it back to me and if I still don't like it I'll just tell them I only want the stone and get the ring made elsewhere.










Overall I really like the ring, here's a few more pics of it.

 

[cabbitstar]

It looks like the setting vise bit into the metal. They should be able to polish that out for you. Congrats on the very pretty diamond!

 

[plummiecat]

Your ring is beautiful! I would be unhappy with the scratches and would send it back to the jeweler to have it polished or receive a new setting.

 

[GirlyGirl]

I'm glad they are offering to fix it. It may just need a quick polish. Your ring is lovely.