Hello, I am proposing on Christmas Eve at the tree in NYC. My question is should I wait until its dark outside or when the sun is just starting to set. I would like to do it at night but am afraid it will be too dark, but then again the area should be slightly lit with the tree. Now here is my idea: My girlfriend is really into dogs but does not have one and cannot have one. I wanted to have a puppy run up to us or at least have an owner walk the dog towards us with the ring box around its neck, my girlfriend would pet the dog and notice the box around its neck, i would then remove the box open it (i would already be on one knee petting the dog) and present her with the ring. Now what I need is to find a dog owner who can help me (i will throw them a $20 if they would like) or is their anyway I can borrow a dog for a day? I have never heard of it but I am thinking about going to an animal shelter and asking one of the employees if they can do it for me. Anyone have any advice.