How true is this statement about color

[Vegasvick]

This is from the diamonds pro website

"Second, if you’re buying a round brilliant cut diamond. As we mentioned in our guide to diamond color, the round brilliant cut is excellent at concealing yellow coloration. If you choose any grade higher than H, you’re paying for a feature you simply won’t be able to see."

is this accurate?

relevant to larger stones say 1.8 carat and up ??

 

[rocks]

If you are color sensitive you will see color in anything but “d”...but few people are that color sensitive.

 

[Rons Wolfe]

That depends on several factors, including the viewer's eyes. I can certainly tell my H from my higher colored stones face-up. Not that I love my H any less.

 

[lovedogs]

It depends on the size of the stone and your personal sensitivity. I cannot see the difference between an ideal cut G (sometimes H) versus D unless they are upsidedown and next to each other, but I am not color sensitive.

 

[KristinTech]

Absolutely not true. Everyone is different. I am color sensitive, but I can tolerate (and enjoy) color in certain pieces. In my engagement ring and anniversary diamonds, I wanted colorless. @RunningwithScissors is a superseer, she can pluck out her ice queen D diamonds with relative ease, I’m sure.

 

[Vegasvick]

Great responses, it just seemed like such strong statement i wanted verify

 

[RunningwithScissors]

That statement is NOT true.

I can easily select a D out of a line up of D-E-F-G diamonds. I've done it many times in many different lighting situations.

Both biology and training account for the ability to discern subtle color variations.

Preference is different than the ability to see the variation. Some people like cool, colorless diamonds, while others prefer warmer ones.

There is also contrast to take into account. What you place next to a diamond (or any object) affects your perception of the color and tone of that object.

For example, my diamond engagement ring looks a lot lighter in tone when my husband wears it, then when I am wearing it (my husband is much darker complected than I am and the contrast is greater on him.)

 

[nala]

If this statement was true, why bother assigning color grades?

 

[whitewave]

Someone once told me H is the color most sold. I’m not sure if that is particular to that one place, or a verifiable fact..

 

[La2020]

Is it true that face-up, the H-I-J looks very similar to the D-E-F-G ranges but the flashes in D-E-F-G is whiter/"icy", as compared to the colorful/yellow flashes in H-I-J ranges?

 

[asterismdispersion]

At one gem show I heard a vendor make a similar statement: "we do not stock any diamonds in colors higher than 'G' since anything whiter than that is paying for a difference that can't be seen face up." I only had an I colored stone at the time but considered this to be a sales pitch I had overheard instead of solid advice.

Like others have stated, I can detect a slight difference in tone between my E and H-I diamonds. H takes more focus for me to discern the little bit of tint. (I do not have a G colored stone for reference.) Yes, I can make out the comparative lack of tint in the facets flashing on an E vs H color.

 

[stepcutsoiree]

I think that is not entirely true. Anything below F, I can usually see the yellowish tint.

100% of the time, I see color in anything under a G.

 

[AllAboardTheBlingTrain]

As others have said, it’s not true that you can’t see (as in they are completely identical to the eye) colour in an H / the difference between D and H is non existent. But whether you’ll be okay with an H or lower (I, J, even K) is something only you can answer. I’m not particularly colour sensitive (probably unusually colour tolerant) so for me H-I is my sweet spot but I’ve seen an L and considered that reasonably white too.

 

[LightBright]

i can see color nuances and prefer diamonds that are E or D. Even some GIA Fs look slightly tinted to me. However, if the wearer isn’t color sensitive, I agree with the statement. I know of several 2 plus carat GIA G diamonds discussed on Pricescope that looked too yellow to the buyer.

 

[monipod]

My ER is a sweet .33ct MRB set in yellow gold bezel. I barely remember what colour it was graded (I think G or H) and had it been a D, I wouldn't have noticed. Fast forward 20 years later, if I had a 2+ ct stone set in white gold, I would notice the difference between H and DEF easily as I know what I'm looking for now, or I'm conscious of it.

That said, the statement is probably accurate for a good majority of people (especially here in Australia) who are new to buying diamonds and aren't looking at anything above 1ct.

 

[Karl_K]

Someone once told me H is the color most sold. I’m not sure if that is particular to that one place, or a verifiable fact..

It was true for a lot of years but since the price increases it would not surprise me if it is now I.
For many years a good balance of properties vs price was the g-h range vs/si.
With the most common even today budget range of $5k-$6k for the mean budget for a engagement ring and for many years you could hit a well cut 1ct and a nice setting in that G-H range.
These days you have to go to I-J for that price range.
PS preference has followed suite as more people discovered there is nothing wrong with diamonds under H.

 

[whitewave]

It was true for a lot of years but since the price increases it would not surprise me if it is now I.
For many years a good balance of properties vs price was the g-h range vs/si.
With the most common even today budget range of $5k-$6k for the mean budget for a engagement ring and for many years you could hit a well cut 1ct and a nice setting in that G-H range.
These days you have to go to I-J for that price range.
PS preference has followed suite as more people discovered there is nothing wrong with diamonds under H.

I’ve recently been sold on K color for super ideals, so I can see how I could be the new H. I think K is the new J.

 

[Niel]

You’ll see it yes how could anything be 5 shades different and you not notice.
Will you care? Hard to say.
There’s a difference between seeing and being bothered by it.

 

[headlight]

This is from the diamonds pro website

"Second, if you’re buying a round brilliant cut diamond. As we mentioned in our guide to diamond color, the round brilliant cut is excellent at concealing yellow coloration. If you choose any grade higher than H, you’re paying for a feature you simply won’t be able to see."

is this accurate?

relevant to larger stones say 1.8 carat and up ??

Completely disagree 100%.

 

[La2020]

Is it true that face-up, the H-I-J looks very similar to the D-E-F-G ranges but the flashes in D-E-F-G is whiter/"icy", as compared to the colorful/yellow flashes in H-I-J ranges?

Found it! Here it is...

 

[Vegasvick]

Found it! Here it is...

From this picture i can definitely see the yellow tinge in KLM, a bit harder to notice face up on h-j but again this is all on a picture.

 

[Karl_K]

From this picture i can definitely see the yellow tinge in KLM, a bit harder to notice face up on h-j but again this is all on a picture.

Which looks different on every monitor so no 2 people see the same thing.

 

[La2020]

I saw a k before.. Definitely yellow even from face up.. My spouse noticed the yellow too.

 

[diamondseeker2006]

I'd be wary of that site if they made a statement that ridiculous.

 

[Estrella185]

I saw a k before.. Definitely yellow even from face up.. My spouse noticed the yellow too.

We also need to remember that as you go down in color those colors have ranges, for instance not all J stones look the same in tone. I have what would be considered a “high” J which looks more like a H/I. I’ve found color to be very subjective, so many things to consider ( fluorescents , setting metal etc. ) all have a bearing on how the diamond will appear to the eye.

 

[Rockdiamond]

ANY generalized statement is simply not true!!!
Wait

Seriously- I'm in agreement with those that find the statement totally off base- and could easily be seen as misleading.

 

[whitewave]

I saw a k before.. Definitely yellow even from face up.. My spouse noticed the yellow too.

My HPD K color

 

[MamaBee]

My HPD K color

That looks sooo white @whitewave!

 

[Ibrakeforpossums]

My HPD K color

Perfect. Thank you!!

 

[La2020]

My HPD K color

That is so pretty, looks white faceup!