How important are perfect hearts?

[Gustavoboy106]

I will decide between a perfect H&A from Whiteflash at premium prices, or choose a bigger and whiter diamond at a not so perfect cut

This is Whiteflash 2.1 J



This Is 2.4 F


2.3 F



Proportions:


My first option now is 2.4, then 2.3 and last 2.1.

Finger size 5.5

I love other 2 diamonds because of size and color, also good proportions, but not perfect hearts, which should you choose?

 

[flyingpig]

I would go whiter and bigger

 

[AprilBaby]

Whiter color

 

[indirak]

I'd definitely go with one of the two larger, whiter ones. I think the specs look great for both. I'd do the 2.4 personally.

 

[Gustavoboy106]

Thanks everyone!

The 2.4 sold!

They're is a 2.5 G color but is IGI (so it could be H, I leave pic below to check color)

Table: 57.5%
Depth: 62.2
Crown:35.3
Pav: 40.9



Or the 2.3 E color GIA (proportions above)

What do you think?

 

[indirak]

I'd lean towards the 2.3, mainly because it's GIA certified. Are there pictures of it?

The color looks good for the 2.5, but I'm not seeing 8 defined arrows in that picture. The two horizontal in the center kinda fade away. I'm not sure how important that is, but just a thought.

 

[Gustavoboy106]

I leave videos here:

Dropbox - Error - Simplify your life

www.dropbox.com

Dropbox - Error - Simplify your life

www.dropbox.com

 

[headlight]

Can you post the GIA report?
I would pick a GIA E color over anything IGI.

 

[Gustavoboy106]

 

[Gustavoboy106]

I am still waiting for ASET they are slow because of virus I think. But both look good in video I think.

First video es 2.3 and second is 2.5

I kinda like the 2.5 because of size an G color still is good even if it has a very slight tint of light yellow. I think in real life will look very white.

The 2.3 E will be transparent but little smaller so.. is my dilema now

 

[headlight]

@Gustavoboy106 You are in the trade?

 

[Gustavoboy106]

I don't trade, this is for my gf, but I have researched a lot for this.

I have been thinking that I really like this, so would like to do so in the future, but not right now.