Honest opinions on two ovals please!

[MrsDiamondDee]

Hi all!

I am a first-time poster, long-time lurker, and I am in the process of upgrading my engagement ring, burn I feel like I can't pick my centre diamond without the collective expertise of the PS community!

These are two loose stones I am not interested in:

The first three photos are of a 2ct, E, Vs2, excellent polish, excellent symmetry, four mains.

The second three photos are of a 1.87, D, VS1, excellent polish, excellent symmetry, eight mains.

I have videos, but for some reason I can't upload them, so these are some screen shots from the video- which would you pick (or would you pick neither)?

Your opinions are much appreciated!!

 

[tyty333]

Did you get ASET images for them? If so, please post.

I'm not usually a fan of 4 mains but I cant even see the faceting pattern in the pictures. Please keep trying to load the videos. They may* help.

 

[MrsDiamondDee]

Unfortunately the when I try to upload the video, I receive an error message that says the file does not have an allowed extension... not sure what that means . I also do not have ASET images