Find your diamond
Find your jewelry
shape
carat
color
clarity

Here is the engagement ring - honest opinions pls: be gentle!

I think it is beautiful! Finger coverage + more bling = What''s not to like??
2.gif
 
Proportions are a matter of opinion. I happen to like larger size stones for presence and coverage. I think the ring is gorgeous and using a family stone makes it so special
 
OMG! There''s no way to be gentle with this one... it''s GORGEOUS!! How how do I convince you to send it to me? hehe
 
It looks fantastic and has a lot of finger coverage! I have a 3 stone as well and my side stones are also very close in size to my center stone like yours. It makes for a very blingy ring. You did a great job! Enjoy!
 
I actually like the proportion
36.gif
Larger side stones means more finger coverage and bling bling. What''s there not to love?
2.gif
 
It''s gorgeous!!! I especially LOVE the side profile! Congrats!!!
 
That is some serious bling!!! I love it!!!
 
Really!?! Whats not to like??? That is a fingerful of bling. Love it!
 
Well, there''s nothing to have to be gentle about - it''s ABSOLUTELY gorgeous!!!! i love the proportions - it''s so beautiful :)
 
I have a similarly proportioned three stone (sapphire and two diamonds) that I wear as a combo engagement/wedding band. I love it and get compliments on it all the time--worn on the third finger of the left hand and people know what it is....

I will say that at that height it might have a tendency to get caught when putting hands in pockets, etc. Because it is not a solitare, it won't slide to the side quite as easily. You might let her know after she's received the ring with great delight that if she prefers that you can have the setting lowered if she wants.

Best wishes to you both!
 
Beautiful, and that''s an honest opinion
30.gif
 
I think it looks lovely. I would be quite happy to have this ring. Don''t feel like you need to apoologize for anything to do with it.
 
I love it and wouldn''t change a thing!!!!!
 
I LOVE IT! It''s gorgeous. Talk about bling! It''s stunning.
 
I don''t think it looks like an anniversary band at all, honestly. I think it''s gorgeous! Like some previous posters said, it''s a bit high for my taste, but that''s just me being nit-picky. It''s a personal preference thing.
 
Very pretty! I like it very much!
 
Honest opinion: you couldn''t have done better
1.gif
 
Honest opinion - the ring rocks! It is beautiful!
 
The proportions are perfect and your ring is gorgeous!
 
Very graceful and elegant...lovely!!! Does NOT look like an anniversary ring...looks like a gorgeous 3 stone beauty!
 
its absolutely lovely!

frankly, an girl who doesn''t love that is a brat! i''m sure she will LOVE it!

30.gif
 
It totally looks like an engagement ring. She''ll love it! It''s beautiful and I love the fact that you were able to include a family heirloom.
 
I think adding a family heirloom is more special than anything, you really did a great job! Congrats!
 
beautiful!!!! and I love how you tied in you family history!
 
Beautiful ring!!! Don''t forget to come back with hand shots!!!
 
it''s very pretty !
 
I think it''s VERY nice. I have seen an ering like that before so no worries. Love that you were able to use a family stone. Enjoy it!
9.gif
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
GET 3 FREE HCA RESULTS JOIN THE FORUM. ASK FOR HELP
Jewelry Blog
PriceScope-Concierge-Ad
Find prime cuts.
Top