Help with depth of antique style OMC

[petrock<3]

Hi all! I need help with dimensions of old mines.

I have my old mine I love but may have the opportunity to swap it for a higher color but same cut style shape and size and everything.

But I’m looking at the depth, the depth of mine is 7.26 mm and the possible new one is only 6.55 mm. I know antique cuts are supposed to be on the deeper side.

My stone: 11.08 x 9.46 x 7.26

New one: 11.68 x 9.88 x 6.55

Are these dimensions ok? Thank you

 

[Dreamer_D]

Can say much just with that info. Sorry! Do you have lab reports or pictures?

 

[newtojewels]

My natural antique old mine is 9.38 x 8.47 x 5.76 which is a similar depth percentage to the new one you're looking at (68% for mine versus 66% for yours). I don't think a 66% depth is worrisome in and of itself if the rest of the diamond is cut well with a small table and nice crisp facet pattern. Do you have photos/videos?

 

[Karl_K]

Could be, this is kinda like asking is a 1 foot high dog friendlier than a 10 inch high dog.
All joking aside we would need images and preferably 360 video of the new stone to help you.

 

[petrock<3]

Ok I just secured the deposit so I can post details

Thanks everybody

 

[petrock<3]

Could be, this is kinda like asking is a 1 foot high dog friendlier than a 10 inch high dog.
All joking aside we would need images and preferably 360 video of the new stone to help you.

Hehehe thank you
I have a video I’ll upload it’s also on Alex’s IG page