Help with ASET images

[Archi78]

Hi guys, I need help to read ASET images provided from JA, about three princess cut diamonds I'm intersted in.
I received the JA gemologist judge through email but I want to ask you what you think about ASETs results.
From left to right, the first one is 0.58 carat G-VVS2 ideal cut, polish very good, simmetry very good.
The center one is 0.59 carat G-VVS2 ideal cut, polish excellent, simmetry very good.
The right one is 0.64 carat G-VVS1 ideal cut, polish excellent, simmetry very good.
I would be very glad if someone of you would help me understanding which one would be the best choice for my engagement ring.
Thank you so much for your help
Pierre

 

[madelise]

The one in the middle would drive me nuts with the pattern of leakage. The 3rd one a little less nuts. I'd go with the first one.

 

[sakari_8]

I would choose first one, I see all the stones you chose are VVS clarity, I think if you go with VS Clarity with bigger size in same budget,
VVS or VS would appear same to naked eyes.

 

[Archi78]

Thank you for your answers! The reason why I decided to ask for help on this forum is because the report of the JA in-house gemologist is this:

"I am happy to tell you that she found all three to be very beautiful, lively options. Her favorite of the three was the 0.64 carat-G-VVS1 because it has the balance of brilliance (white light return), with a great amount of fire (dispersion of color) and sparkle. The 0.59 carat-G-VVS2 is a very close second. It too has an excellent amount of brilliance, fire and sparkle that is well balanced and symmetrical, just not as favorable as the 0.64 carat. The 0.58 carat-G-VVS2 is a very beautiful option and it does have really good performance. The gemologist found it to be the weakest of the three compared to these two. All three diamonds are a very beautiful white color and face up completely "eye clean"."

So you are telling me the opposite of what was said by JA gemoligist! Is this normal?!?
I'm confused..

 

[bunnycat]

Thank you for your answers! The reason why I decided to ask for help on this forum is because the report of the JA in-house gemologist is this:

"I am happy to tell you that she found all three to be very beautiful, lively options. Her favorite of the three was the 0.64 carat-G-VVS1 because it has the balance of brilliance (white light return), with a great amount of fire (dispersion of color) and sparkle. The 0.59 carat-G-VVS2 is a very close second. It too has an excellent amount of brilliance, fire and sparkle that is well balanced and symmetrical, just not as favorable as the 0.64 carat. The 0.58 carat-G-VVS2 is a very beautiful option and it does have really good performance. The gemologist found it to be the weakest of the three compared to these two. All three diamonds are a very beautiful white color and face up completely "eye clean"."

So you are telling me the opposite of what was said by JA gemoligist! Is this normal?!?
I'm confused..

No, that happens a lot. I don't know a thing about princess cuts but wish I could help more than to say you have not been the only one confused...