Help, which stone???please comment!!!

[Diabuyie]

Hi,

I would like your advise on the following round stones with GIA certified:

Weight 1.76 1.71
Color E F
Clarity VVS2 VVS2
% Depth 60.9 61.1
% Table 55 55
Dimensions 7.79x7.85x4.76mm 7.71x7.77x4.73mm
Fluorescence none none
Polish Excel. Excel
Symmetry Excel Excel
Comments TN-M TN-M
Cut PREMIUM PREMIUM

Which of these two do you think is better cut dimensions? I''m not familiar with the dimensions. How can I tell a good dimension???

 

[Dancing Fire]

Date: 12/27/2004 4:33:34 AM
Author:Diabuyie
Hi,

I would like your advise on the following round stones with GIA certified:

Weight 1.76 1.71
Color E F
Clarity VVS2 VVS2
% Depth 60.9 61.1
% Table 55 55
Dimensions 7.79x7.85x4.76mm 7.71x7.77x4.73mm
Fluorescence none none
Polish Excel. Excel
Symmetry Excel Excel
Comments TN-M TN-M
Cut PREMIUM PREMIUM

Which of these two do you think is better cut dimensions? I''m not familiar with the dimensions. How can I tell a good dimension???

ask your vendor for a sarin or ogi report. hard to guess the cut grade without more information.

 

[Regular Guy]

Diabuyie,

This Chart may help you.

Also, couldn't help notice: a) your advice to About2BEngaged, saying: "Why settled for something that is not 100% satifactory...," and also, b) the repeat of Dancing Fire's advice above, given to you mid-month, about the helpfulness of additional data. Even though it sounds like there's a specific vendor you'd like to work with, this doesn't prohibit you from getting that crown & pavilion data. And if it does, are you satisfied with that?

 

[Diabuyie]

Ira Z,

The vendor that I work with does not have a sarin report. I''d satisfy with just this information....until after I read more on this website about the sarin report. Now it makes me wonder how do I get the sarin report within 5days.

 

[Garry H (Cut Nut)]

The vendor can easily make the request and email results. then you can enter the angles etc into HCA under tools on the top bar.

If the vendor has acess to the stone, they could also perhaps take an ideal-scope photo which is more useful than the Sarin #''s.

BTW you should be a little careful about giving others advice when you may not be qualified.

 

[Regular Guy]

Garry,

Point taken...relatively.

Hand waving is perhaps enough.

Also, however, knowledge is power.

If there''s anything in particular it would be helpful to add...don''t be shy.