Help! Which diamond to choose?

[bpp_23]

Hi please help me choose between these round brilliant diamonds, concerned about the table, Pavillon angle and girdle differences-

1. 2.59ct DVVS1, table 58% PA 40.8 girdle medium 3.5%



2. 2.66ct DVVS1 table 57% PA 41.2 girdle medium to slightly thick 4.0%

 

[bpp_23]

I should add that the 2.59ct has a HCA score of 1.3 and the 2.66ct has a HCA score of 1.9

 

[Kim N]

Can you post the video links? We can't evaluate the diamonds solely by the numbers.

 

[Karl_K]

Can you post the video links? We can't evaluate the diamonds solely by the numbers.

Im seeing a lot of treated cvd with crystal issues with a GIA report and they are hiding that info making them way overpriced.

 

[bpp_23]

Can you post the video links? We can't evaluate the diamonds solely by the numbers.

thanks, here are the links. The 2.59ct is the one I’ve paid for but can change to the 2.66ct for a bit extra.

2.59ct

https://novitadiamonds.com/engagement-ring/create/diamond?current-screen=screen-diamond-detail&diamond-selection=2363838

2.66ct

https://novitadiamonds.com/engagement-ring/create/diamond?current-screen=screen-diamond-detail&diamond-selection=1485084

 

[Kim N]

thanks, here are the links. The 2.59ct is the one I’ve paid for but can change to the 2.66ct for a bit extra.

2.59ct

https://novitadiamonds.com/engagement-ring/create/diamond?current-screen=screen-diamond-detail&diamond-selection=2363838

2.66ct

https://novitadiamonds.com/engagement-ring/create/diamond?current-screen=screen-diamond-detail&diamond-selection=1485084

The 2.59 is much better than the 2.66.

 

[bpp_23]

Im seeing a lot of treated cvd with crystal issues with a GIA report and they are hiding that info making them way overpriced.

Can you tell if the above two diamonds have these issues?

 

[bpp_23]

The 2.59 is much better than the 2.66.

Thanks for that! Is it really obvious? I can’t believe I almost paid more for the 2.66

 

[Kim N]

Thanks for that! Is it really obvious? I can’t believe I almost paid more for the 2.66

Yes, it's very clear that the 2.59 is better cut.

 

[0515vision]

I circled the disorganized areas on the 2.66. The 2.59 has much better light return, resulting in a crisp facet pattern. Hope this helps!

 

[lovedogs]

The 2.59 a million times

 

[lovedogs]

Thanks for that! Is it really obvious? I can’t believe I almost paid more for the 2.66

Yup, it's not even close