HELP: Princess Cut ASET experts needed

[piz00]

which one is better?
thanks

 

[piz00]

Please help to choose 1 or 2
Thanks

 

[delight]

1

 

[yssie]

which one is better?
thanks

Actual pics?

 

[piz00]

which one is better?
thanks

Actual pics?

They are

 

[piz00]

1

I like 1 too, but its J color
2 is not bad, isn't it?
What do you think?
Is 1 far better than 2 or are they almost the same sparkle?
Thanks

 

[tyty333]

She was asking for actual images of the stones (not the asets).
Do you have the links? Faceting pattern can play a big role in selecting a princess.

 

[piz00]

She was asking for actual images of the stones (not the asets).
Do you have the links? Faceting pattern can play a big role in selecting a princess.

All I want are brilliance fire and scintillation Please help out.

#1 is J color VS

#2 is I clarity and I was told not eye clean

 

[piz00]

pics
All I want are brilliance fire and scintillation Please help out. Thank you very much.

 

[piz00]

help please

 

[tyty333]

Have you asked the gemologist to compare and contrast the stones and tell you what they see?
Which one would be their recommendation?

You said number 2 is NOT eye clean? Most people would not want a stone that is not eye clean
Plus the inclusion looks like it'd right in the center of the stone.

 

[chel180]

Can you give us the specs and price difference between the two. Then we can tell you the one we prefer overall.

But based on only the photos and ASETs I much prefer 1. It has better light return and looks visually more attractive to me. I couldn't stand a central inclusion like that. Also please remember that a very well cut J will look whiter than a average cut H.

 

[04diamond<3]

I like the faceting on #2 better...Remember, the inclusion in the picture is blow up...

 

[Enerchi]

With only the info given here so far, I'd chose 2 for the faceting and colour. Princesses can easily show more colour, especially in the corners. "I" would be the very lowest I would personally go w a princess stone. I'd prefer to be at a G/H if possible.

 

[piz00]

Thank you guys. price are very close.The gemologist said #1(J color) has a very slight warmth and #2 inclusions in the center can be seen at certain angles
any comments? Thanks again.

 

[piz00]

Please help to make a decision.
Thanks.

 

[04diamond<3]

Thank you guys. price are very close.The gemologist said #1(J color) has a very slight warmth and #2 inclusions in the center can be seen at certain angles
any comments? Thanks again.

If the inclusions can only be seen at certain angles I really wouldn't worry about it. That would be my pick.

 

[piz00]

Thank you guys. price are very close.The gemologist said #1(J color) has a very slight warmth and #2 inclusions in the center can be seen at certain angles
any comments? Thanks again.

If the inclusions can only be seen at certain angles I really wouldn't worry about it. That would be my pick.

Thank you very much.

 

[JulieN]

Is there no third option, perhaps I+ color with no visible inclusions?

 

[tyty333]

If there are no other options, 2 would be my choice. 1 looks to be a bright stone but it doesn't have much contrast so
you really don't notice the faceting pattern that much. Just not that exciting to me.

 

[piz00]

Thanks all of you.