Help Please. Professional Opinion needed

[prettythings5]

Help Please. Professional Opinion needed


If one were to choose between 2 Asscher cut diamond of almost exact parameters , which would be the better choice.

Diamond 1: VS1, E, 1.30ct, 5.96x5.96x4.0mm, depth 67.2%, table 64% , girdle thick, culet: none, polish/symmetry: excellent no fluorescence (report states: inclusion are crystal, needle and pinpoint)


Diamond 2: VS1, E, 1.30ct, 5.96x5.94x4.10mm, depth 69%, table 63% , girdle thick, culet: none, polish/symmetry: excellent no fluorescence (report states: inclusion cloud, feather located on edge)

Would truly appreciate your opinion. Thanks so much!

 

[D&T]

asschers are tricky. do you have an image to at least go with the specs.. not all asschers are cut the same even with similar specs. ASET would be best as well to accompany actual diamond image.

 

[prettythings5]

No unfortunately, I do not have images at this time.

 

[D&T]

well just to give you an idea, both of these have about 69% depth, one has a 63% table and the other has 65% table. Fancy cuts, you really need to see images and ASET and cannot and I wouldn't recommend picking one based on numbers alone. You can see how on the first picture doesn't have the complete windmills and then there are steps that aren't mentioned.