Help on price?!!!!!

[Asscherbee]

Calling all experts! Please weigh in on what you think about these two GIA, non-branded Asschers. Which, based on all the information I have, is the better choice? I have more info on one than the other, so it''s not entirely an even fight, is it? Regardless, this should be fun, because they''re on their way to an appraiser. I''ll post the results when I get them. Thank you!

Stone 1

1.55
H
SI1; Vendor says stone is eye-clean
depth 66.8
table 59
6.67x6.59x4.40
girdle stk
culet: none
sym: good
polish: ex
flour: none
cash: $6,689


Stone 2
1.48
G
VS2; pinpoints are not shown
depth 68.2
table: 61
6.38x6.33x4.32
girdle:stk-thk
culet: none
sym: ex
polish: ex
flour: none
crown angle: 43.7
crown height: 16.6
pav. angle: 55.3
pav. depth: 48.3
ratio: 1.00:1.01
cash: $7,185





Asscherbee

 

[pricescope]

Asscherbee, I wish I could comment on numbers but I'm afraid it is impossible.

Pricewise, #1 has better discount from RAP (24% vs 18%) so it might be a better deal all other factors kept the same.

I also tried to reproduce #2 on DiamCalc using crown and pavilion data but numbers don't add up which is not unusual since more info for minor facets is required.

 

[pricescope]

I just attached GEM file for your pleasure

(You'll need to install GemAdviser to play with it).

 

[Giangi]

#2 has VERY good numbers...