shape
carat
color
clarity

help newbie decide between three stones

mscupcake

Rough_Rock
Joined
Jun 26, 2012
Messages
1
I've been perusing this forum for the past week and I have learned so much. Thank you. Husband and I are celebrating 10 years and are upgrading our ring. Our initial stone was EGL US LA certified 1.01 c, g, ideal cut vvs2. Depth 58.7, Table 59%, crown 32.5, pavillion 41.0 with HCA score of 1. We are attempting to trade in for GIA 1.4 c. I only have the measurements and do not have any pictures or other reports and will have to purchase sight unseen.

#1 1.40 c 7.14 -7.17 x 4.42 G VS2 excellent cut, very good polish very good symmetry. depth 61.7, table 58, crown 35.5, pavillion 40.6 hca 1.5

#2 1.43 c 7.28 - 7.31 x 4.47 G VS2 excellent cut, excellent polish, vg symmetry depth 61.2, table 56, crown 35.5, pavillion 41.0 hca 3.7

#3 1.40 c 7.14 - 7.19 x 4.45 G VS2 excellent cut, excellent polish, excellent symmetry depth 62.1, table 56, crown 36, pavillion 40.8 hca 3.5

all of these are gia certified with no fluorescence. are there certain inclusions that i should try to avoid? There's only one stone that has a HCA score of <2, does that automatically make that the best one? TIA.
 

Dancing Fire

Super_Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Apr 3, 2004
Messages
33,852
really tough to pick w/o more infor. any ideal scope pics?
 
Be a part of the community Get 3 HCA Results
Top