- Joined
- Jan 11, 2006
- Messages
- 58,581
KeN3|1341606091|3229709 said:diamondseeker2006|1341598955|3229618 said:I wouldn't consider an HCA score above 2.5 or so. I would really advise you to look in the 1.4 ct. range and get a well cut stone just below 1.5 because there is a price jump at 1.5.
And IGI is unreliable. You'd have no idea what you'd be getting. You really need to stick with GIA Excellent and just buy the largest diamond within your budget.
The thing is, if given the choice between a piece of crap 1.5 ct. diamond and a very fine 1.4 ct. diamond that appears more beautiful, who would choose the bad 1.5? Everyone has to make this choice unless they happen to have unlimited money. You just happen to be on a diamond forum where good quality diamonds are appreciated and we are not going to encourage you to buy a badly cut diamond!
shld my emphasis be on the cut or on the HCA score? cos i found a few "very good"cuts that have a HCA score of 2.1 to 2.5.. are they recommended in that sense?
Ken, I am skipping a few posts and this may have been answered. A "very good" cut diamond is usually going to have a problem of some kind. The HCA score may be one indicator, but we use it mostly here to weed out the poorer stones from the wide GIA Excellent category. If you go with very good, just be sure the diameter is at least 7.35mm or else the stone is going to look smaller than 1.5 cts.
You also do not want to venture into I1 clarity. By definition those are going to have eye visible inclusions almost all the time. Even SI2 will be challenging, but that is more possible to find.
I really think you need to communicate with her that your budget and her size desires do not match. If you are planning to spend your life with this person, she is either going to need to understand a budget or you are going to have serious problems. Or if you want to give her everything she wants, then you are going to have to postpone the engagement and save more money or else get a loan to buy this ring. It isn't easy today to do a nice quality one carat to 1.2 ct. ring at $7000.