Help me pick! Images attached

[tag4u]

Hi,

I am in process of buying 5 small solitaires. I have shortlisted few and the vendor sent me some of the ASET scope images of these diamonds.

Solitaire 1
http://diamondtransactions.net/Search/Details_Item.aspx?gia=5186994371&carat=0.23&SID=3zze7foo05fpk6b12ng4

E/IF/3EX/Table 58, Depth 60.9, Crown Angle 34 and Pavilion Angle 40.8 -> HCA score 1.1



Solitaire 2
http://diamondtransactions.net/Search/Details_Item.aspx?gia=5196263497&carat=0.23&SID=3zze7foo05fpk6b12ng4
E/IF/3EX/Table 58, Depth 60.9, Crown Angle 34 and Pavilion Angle 40.8 -> HCA score 1.1



I have attached both solitaire images. Let me know if this is a great score and good diamond?


I have a third one solitaire with a different dimensions
E/IF/3EX/Table 57, Depth 61, Crown Angle 34 and Pavilion Angle 40.8, Medium 3.5% Girdle -> HCA score 1.0
Don't have images for this, but is this a good bet?

Regards,
Tag

 

[diamondseeker2006]

I think the stone looks fine. I wouldn't pay for IF, but if that is important to you, that's fine. VS1 and up are completely clean to the eye and inclusions will be difficult to see with a 10x loupe.

As far as additional stones go matching the diameter is more important than matching weight. Then keep the table size and angles close but they don't have to be exact.

 

[tag4u]

Thanks a TON. Have checked few VVS2/VVS1 but many had feather near to the surface. (Pinpoint too). Heard that feather near to surface is a deal breaker.