Help me finding diamond!

[ktc]

Hi,

I''ve narrowed down my choices to the 5 stones below, but I cannot decide which one I should go for...
Any comments would be appreciated. Please help me decide

1) 1.09 Carat/I/SI1 - $5,608

2) 1.023 Carat/H/SI1 - $6,105

3) 1.144 Carat/I/VS2 - $6,105

4) 1.05 Carat/H/SI2 - $5,513

5) 1.016 Carat/F/SI2 - 5,654

Thanks a lot for your help,
ktc

 

[pahoyafan]

All 5 look like great performers from the numbers and the ideal-scopes. If I were you, I would call whiteflash and schedule an over-the-phone appointment with someone who can pull the 5 stones. Then, you can find out if the SI2''s and the SI1''s are eyeclean and take it from there with size and color.

 

[diamondseeker2006]

I would rule out the SI2''s because they are too close in price to the others not to go with better clarity.

My choice would be between number 2 and number 3. One has better color and the other better clarity. I wish there was an H VS2, as that is what I''d choose from a list like this! But the I VS2 does have a larger diameter so may appear a bit larger. So I would probably call WF and ask them to look at these two and tell me if there is a discernable color difference and whether that H SI 1 is completely eye-clean. If the colors are too close to tell the difference to a casual observer, then I''d take the larger I VS2 stone #3.

 

[belle]

you really can''t go wrong with any of those, they are all great looking stones. you have decide what you are comfortable with color/clarity wise and go from there. also, as pahoyafan suggets, give them a call. they can help in matching a stone to your requirements.
best of luck!

 

[ktc]

Thank you all for your kind help.

I will contact WF, and check the color and clarity.

ktc