Help me find my Asscher

[yault]

Hello Pricescope! You guys are completely amazing and have taught me so much in my month of lurking the forums. I've been on a hunt to find a great Asscher for my GF, and I think I'm at the stage where I can start asking for everyone's honest feedback.

My top prioritiy is the Cut: I really want it to sparkle and have a great pattern. Overall I've been looking for more of the octagonal look to the square emerald shape.

Here's the first stone I had called in. I should be getting a second one next week. Please let me know where you think the issues might be.

Asscher
1.31
F
VS1
GIA
Depth - 66.7
Table - 64
Grdl - md-stk
Cul - no
Sym - vg
Pol - ex
Flr - no
1.01:1

 

[yault]

2nd Pic

 

[yault]

IS

 

[yault]

Sarin

 

[strmrdr]

the windmills are a bit off but thats pretty common.
Couple places that a little different angles would be better.
Its not a dog but its not top end, maybe one step down.

 

[yault]

Thanks strm, I need all the feedback I can get!

Personally I think it''s a nice looking diamond, not the best I''ve seen, but still very nice.

I''ve been looking for over a month now and still don''t have anything to show for it. My self-imposed deadline is looming closer and closer and asschers seem to be hard to come by at the moment. I''ve got a few vendors searching for my diamond right now, but I''m wondering if I should continue to hold out for a better stone or just take the plunge on this one... Anyone else want to comment?