Help me choose between these 2!

[mr.bebot]

Hi guys! First off, thanks to this site I'm so much more educated and comfortable shopping for diamonds.

I've narrowed it down to 2 almost identical stones, please tell me if I should take one over the other and why.

Diamond 1

Diamond 2(Slightly Smaller)

The first has an HCA of 1.5, the second 1.1 I don't think that really matters at this point. Jamie @ WF has been super helpful and has suggested the second one in her comparison and I have the utmost faith in her. I guess I just wanted final confirmation from the fine members of this forum.

I may even be splitting hairs but it's really important to me and I just want everything right (Like everyone else!)

Thanks!

 

[Ellen]

It is splitting hairs.

So go with the one she suggests, as she is being your eyes for you.

 

[:)]

Date: 8/6/2008 2:16:42 PM
Author: Ellen
It is splitting hairs.

So go with the one she suggests, as she is being your eyes for you.

Ditto!