Help me choose an eternity band. WF vs SP

[bobacha]

Guys..
need your help to decide on a wedding band..

I like the look of a shared prong eternity band and have narrowed my choices into 2:

1. WF''s Diamond for an Eternity, which is actually a 3/4 eternity, 20 round diamonds = 0.8 tcw
http://www.whiteflash.com/Wedding_Bands/Diamonds-for-an-Eternity--3-4-_1069.htm#

2. Facets Collection / Signed Pieces, 32 round diamonds = 0.83 tcw
http://www.signedpieces.com/item.cfm?item_id=3990

My engagement ring is a 0.80ct solitaire white gold ( Stuller Solstice setting, size 6.5), pictured below.
Which one do you think will look better with my e-ring ?

 

[rockzilla]

I vote for the WF mainly because there is a little "room" in the back where there aren''t any diamonds. Even though this means you don''t have the full "eternity" look, I think it is a little more practical for a ring you are going to wear possibly forever...that way you can resize it if ever becomes necessary.

Also, it looks like the WF diamonds are each a little bigger because of this...always a plus!

 

[ImpatientOne]

Exactly

Date: 1/29/2007 3:43:18 PM
Author: rockzilla
I vote for the WF mainly because there is a little ''room'' in the back where there aren''t any diamonds. Even though this means you don''t have the full ''eternity'' look, I think it is a little more practical for a ring you are going to wear possibly forever...that way you can resize it if ever becomes necessary.

Also, it looks like the WF diamonds are each a little bigger because of this...always a plus!

Exactly why I voted for the WF, too!

 

[mrssalvo]

I like the fact that SP has a trade up policy and also a great return policy on their eternity bands, so I voted for the SP's one. I also just have a mental thing that I like a full eternity.

 

[kcoursolle]

I didn''t vote because I couldn''t decide. Both are good choices, you really can''t go wrong here!

 

[Rock Candy]

Date: 1/29/2007 4:11:01 PM
Author: mrssalvo
I like the fact that SP has a trade up policy and also a great return policy on their eternity bands, so I voted for the SP''s one. I also just have a mental thing that I like a full eternity.

I also like the full eternity band at that size. Rings tend to "twirl" and with a full eternity band, you will always have the diamonds showing.

 

[belle]

Date: 1/29/2007 3:43:18 PM
Author: rockzilla
I vote for the WF mainly because there is a little ''room'' in the back where there aren''t any diamonds. Even though this means you don''t have the full ''eternity'' look, I think it is a little more practical for a ring you are going to wear possibly forever...that way you can resize it if ever becomes necessary.

Also, it looks like the WF diamonds are each a little bigger because of this...always a plus!

all good points. it just comes down to what matters most to you!
i didn''t vote because i think they are both fine choices, you just have decide which ''package'' fits you best.

have fun deciding! i can''t wait to see what you get!

 

[bobacha]

Thanks for the responses. I know I can always count on PS''ers

Good to hear that I can''t go wrong with either one of these. I will dig PS archive to see more discussions/comparisons between them.

 

[Sundial]

Hard choice because I love Whiteflash diamonds, but I voted for the Facets because it is full eternity. I think a narrow band like that will turn over a lot and if it were me it would drive me crazy to have that metal strip showing!

 

[Maisie]

Do shared prong eternity bands dig in your other fingers? I think they look beautiful but I would worry I might get sore fingers.

Also with shared prong are the diamonds more safe than pave or melee?

 

[justjulia]

Date: 1/29/2007 6:26:46 PM
Author: Maisiebelle
Do shared prong eternity bands dig in your other fingers? I think they look beautiful but I would worry I might get sore fingers.

Also with shared prong are the diamonds more safe than pave or melee?

I have a shared prong full eternity and it is very comfortable. Really. Very.