Help me choose a Diamond

[turbotime]

Hello everyone,


Could someone possibly tell me which of the following diamonds is "better" in terms of cut(not so much color/calrity). Be feel free to be VERY critical.


If I do opt to go for the I VS2 instead of the G VS1, would the diamond color be noticeably different face up in the ring?



Here is the G VS1

 

[turbotime]

Here is the I VS2:

 

[stone-cold11]

Both are good. Colors maybe if you have them side by side, depends on your color sensitivity.

 

[yssie]

Not a whit of difference in cut quality - both are as good as it gets

This is a decision to be made solely on colour/clarity/cost - you've got the hardest C covered

.


I would say that you will see a difference side by side, but it would be much harder to pick up the tint in the I when alone and set - esp. in this size. Not saying you won't see the tint - you might, but it won't be glaringly "brown" or "yellow", just less - stark and icy.

 

[turbotime]

I noticed it states "Additional clouds not shown" and "Clouds not shown" under comments in the AGS reports. Is this normal? Does anyone know exactly what this means?

 

[stone-cold11]

It means there are additional clouds inclusions, which are not grade setting, not plotted on the inclusion plot. nothing to worry about. It will be worrying for SI and lower grades if the comment is ''grade setting clouds not shown''.

 

[Dancing Fire]

i''ll take the first one.