Help me choose a Diamond out of these 4.

[EXCITEDandANXIOUS]

Can someone please help me decide which one of these Diamonds are better..... They are all H except the last one .... its F

These are all Princess cut diamonds

#1 H - SI1 Measurements: 5.54x5.53x3.7 mm
Depth Percentage: 66.9% Table Percentage: 83%
Girdle - Thick Polish - Very Good Symmetry - Very Good
Fluorescence: None
#2 H - VS2 Measurements: 5.4x5.36x3.88 mm
Depth: 72.4% Table: 79%
Girdle: - (unknow I guess) Polish: Very Good Symmetry: Good
Fluor: None
#3 H - VS2 Measurements: 5.45x5.16x4.05 mm
Depth: 78.6% Table: 74%
Girdle: Medium Polish: Good Symmetry: Very Good
Fluor: None
#4 F - SI2 Measurements: 5.62x5.43x3.48 mm
Depth: 64% Table: 77%
Girdle: (unknown) Polish: Good Symmetry: Fair
Fluor: None Note: This one has a comment that says its eye-clean

Thanks in Advance......

 

[belle]

i would run the other way on all of them. they are very shallow with large tables... not usually a combination that makes for the best looking diamonds.

 

[windowshopper]

Date: 5/20/2006 11:06:28 PM
Author: belle
i would run the other way on all of them. they are very shallow with large tables... not usually a combination that makes for the best looking diamonds.

didnt want to be the first but i agree

 

[EXCITEDandANXIOUS]

Hi...thank you for answering.

I really don''t know much about diamonds. How can I tell if they are shallow and/or with large tables. Can you please teach me a thing or two.

thanks

 

[JulieN]

Shallow depth is below 68 or 70.

Large table is, for me, above 70, although up to about 72/73 is still ok (if you like the large tabled look.)