Help! E VS2 or G VVS2?

[ggg072]

Please help me decide between these two. They are both 1.21ct 3ex and no fluoro (GIA). #2 is cheaper than #1 (about USD300 cheaper).
#1
G VVS2
table 57
CA 34.5
crown height: 15
PA 40.6
pavillion height: 43
Total depth:61.4
girdlle medium(faceted 3.5%) LGL 75
inclusions: Needle and cloud on table (comments: pinpoints are not shown)
cha 0.8

#2
E VS2
table 56
CA 35
crown height: 15.5
PA 40.8
pavillion height: 43
Total depth:61.9
girdlle thin to medium(faceted 3.5%) LGL 75
inclusions: crystal and needle on table (comments: cloud are not shown. pinpoints are not shown)
hca 1.6

I dont have Idealscop and ASET. Based on the data, which one would you choose? PLEASE HELP!

 

[rockysalamander]

#2 by the numbers.

Are these your only choices? Have you looked online?

 

[bearberrybear]

#2 by the numbers.

Are these your only choices? Have you looked online?

They are from blueniles. They don’t provide ideal scope and ASET

 

[gm89uk]

You can't select either based on the numbers, both have great potential. Face on photos at least will help tremendously

 

[PintoBean]

If you are serious about those stones you coujld reach out to a vendor like IDJ to see if the stones are in the US. If so, they can call them in and do the images for you to present to the forum for feedback.