Help! Debating between two 4 carat stones

[Chicagobears77]

Thanks everyone for the detailed input, I saw both in person and preferred the I. I thought it looked great in person even vs other comparable diamonds. I’m evaluating one more stone (will post if it’s worth it) but otherwise likely to select it.

 

[Chicagobears77]

I found one more stone which I actually prefer for a little more money. Slightly bigger and VS2 without twinning wisps so it shines brighter. I've seen it in person and it looks great even next to diamond 1, any issue with the images before I say yes?

Thanks!

DIAMOND 3
4.18, I, VS2, Excellent

 

[skypie]

Maybe it's just the photos but does it looks like the table is misaligned a bit? Like someone shifted it a tiny bit too far to the left?

 

[SimoneDi]

#1 between these two

 

[ac117]

I still prefer the smaller table and chubbier arrows of #1 BUT if the twinning wisps are effecting transparency, then I would certainly choose #3. The images show strong light return so I'm sure it's a pretty stone...you saw and compared them in person and preferred #3 so trust your own eyes!