Help comparing two diamonds

[PLM3]

Hi all,

Please help me compare these two diamonds! They're almost identical (color, size, etc.) so really just looking for thoughts from the forum. To me, option 2 is definitely darker in the spot light but this helps the colors pop to me, they are very similar looking in daylight and diffuse light . Appreciate any thoughts, thanks!

Option 1 (left hand stone in video)
2.00 H VS2 3X, No Fl, additional pinpoints not shown (is this an issue?), 8.12-8.14mm




Option 2 (right hand stone in video)
2.01 I VS2 3X, Med Fl, pinpoints not shown (is this an issue?), surface graining is not shown (is this an issue?) 8.14-8.17mm

 

[Kim N]

I prefer the proportions and color of the first one.

 

[Garry H (Cut Nut)]

I will look yellowish in some indoor lighting but may look whiter than the H in other light with some UV.
Surface graining can mean undetected internal graining and in that case the I stone may have lower brilliance in light with UV present.