help comparing 2 diamonds

[kmk42019]

I am down to 2 diamonds and want some help in deciding...both are the same price

First one:
GIA triple exc
Clarity- SI2
Table-57
Depth-62
Crown angle-34.8
Pavilion angle-40.8
Girdle-4.4%



Second one:
GIA triple exc
Clarity-SI2
Table-58
Depth-62.1
Crown-34.9
Pavilion-40.8
girdle-4.2%

 

[Andelain]

#1.

#2 has leakage under the table.

 

[kmk42019]

What about the white area at the 7 and 2 o'clock positions?

 

[Andelain]

What about the white area at the 7 and 2 o'clock positions?

Won't be noticeable once the stone isn't hugely magnified.