Help ! Choosing btw 2 rocks.

[bigbluebird]

Hi everyone, First time posting. Thanks in advance for all inputs.

I am deciding btw 2 rocks.

1) Colour F, VS2
TOTAL DEPTH PERCENTAGE = 61.8%
TABLE SIZE PERCENTAGE = 56%
CROWN HEIGHT PERCENTAGE = 15.4%
CROWN ANGLE = 34.9°
PAVILION DEPTH PERCENTAGE = 43.3%
PAVILION ANGLE = 40.9°
GIRDLE THICKNESS = Medium
GIRDLE FINISH = Faceted
CULET = none
LOWER HALF LENGTH PERCENTAGE = 80%
STAR LENGTH PERCENTAGE = 55%

This gives a HCA score of 1.7






2) colour G, VS2
TOTAL DEPTH PERCENTAGE = 62.1%
TABLE SIZE PERCENTAGE = 55%
CROWN HEIGHT PERCENTAGE = 16%
CROWN ANGLE = 35.3°
PAVILION DEPTH PERCENTAGE = 43%
PAVILION ANGLE = 40.7°
GIRDLE THICKNESS = Thin to Medium
GIRDLE FINISH = Faceted
CULET = none
LOWER HALF LENGTH PERCENTAGE = 75%
STAR LENGTH PERCENTAGE = 50%

HCA Score 1.4






First of all, not an easy task to take nice photos since both were already set on a ring. Both diamonds looks great under ideascope (with difficulties given both on a ring) with nice arrows. Noticed the fatter arrows due on one due to 75% LGF. Optically hard to tell them apart. Fatter arrows is slightly bigger diamond but colour G.


Any thoughts ?

 

[Kim N]

Are you able to take Ideal-Scope images? From these photos, I like the second one better.

 

[ecf8503]

I like the second one better as well, but are those inclusions under the table at 6:00?

 

[bigbluebird]

Are you able to take Ideal-Scope images? From these photos, I like the second one better.

I tried but unable to take a decent photo. Both have beautiful arrows. Down to Fat vs Skinny arrows. Plus colour G (bigger diamond too) vs colour F (smaller diamond).
Also all cut parameters on skinny arrow diamond are within the “ideal cut” range, whereas few parameters on the fatter arrows diamond are out of the “ideal” range

 

[bigbluebird]

I like the second one better as well, but are those inclusions under the table at 6:00?

Those are not inclusion. Dust.

 

[headlight]

I’m not a fan of the fat arrows and I would prefer higher color anyhow.

 

[lovedogs]

Second one because I adore the fatter arrows