Help choosing between diamonds

[cypress123]

I am trying to decide between two diamonds and wondering if the difference in price is worth it. Also want to know if these are reasonable prices. Thanks in advance for the feedback.

Diamond 1
Shape Round
Lab AGS
Measurements 7.44 - 7.48 x 4.63mm
Carat 1.587
Cut Very Good
Polish Ideal
Symmetry Excellent
Color F
Clarity SI1
Depth 62%
Table 58.60%
Crown Angle 34.4
Pavilion Angle 41.6
Lower Half Length 77%
Star Length 47%
Girdle Faceted, thin to slightly thick
Cutlet
Fluorescence
Price 15,900


Diamond 2
Shape Round
Lab AGS
Measurements 7.36 - 7.40 x 4.52mm
Carat 1.515
Cut Ideal
Polish Ideal
Symmetry Ideal
Color H
Clarity SI1
Depth 61.20%
Table 59.30%
Crown Angle 34.2
Pavilion Angle 41.3
Lower Half Length 79%
Star Length 50%
Girdle Faceted, thin to slightly thick
Cutlet Pointed
Fluorescence Negligible
Price 13,800

 

[ringo865]

NOT AN EXPERT, but wondering why you'd consider paying an additional price for a "very good" cut against an AGS ideal cut? It is more $ because it's an F color not an H, but they're both SI1 clarity, so if they were both eye clean, personally I would go with the ideal cut. H is pretty white.

Are they eye clean?

 

[solgen]

Given those prices though I think you can find better diamonds.

 

[centrifuge41]

Any other choices available? Both are far too steep. Pavilion angle should be <=41°. Neither one would have good light performance.

 

[Gypsy]

The second is terrible. So if the first.

I choose: do not waste your money.

 

[cypress123]

Thanks everyone for the feedback. Why would the the diamond that is ideal in all three facets of the cut be terrible. Having trouble understanding this.