shape
carat
color
clarity

Heavy gold chain with modest mark-up -- would you be tempted?

LilAlex

Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Mar 3, 2018
Messages
3,654
Not a colored-stone question, per se, but let's say I want to put a colored-stone slider on this. You are my peeps so looking for your opinions please!

The same almost-retired B&M jeweler who was selling the oxblood coral has two handmade heavy 18K YG chains -- one a polished graduated link and one a sleek tubogas. They are "new" (unworn; old stock, I suppose), extremely well-made, contemporary, and European (maybe made within the last couple decades) -- one is French and one is German. I went to pick up the ring so it's a little like, "Hey, do you want fries with that?"

When I price them by gram-weight alone (and correct for 18K) and use the high recent spot price for gold, I see that one is only 50% over "melt value" (I hate that term, but whatever) and the other is only 30% over melt value. I am accustomed to 2X -- and that matches what I see on Lang for their heavyweight chains and also what I see on 1st Dibs (recognizing that this is a little inflated). And when I poke around online, I see anywhere from 100% - 400% markup as typical, and even up to 9X. (Presumably the highest markups are the lightest chains.)

I would not buy gold as an investment but this seems tempting. Plus, these are not commoditized "by the foot" machine-made 14K chains. (Also: I know that an elephant for a quarter is only a good deal if you have a quarter and need an elephant.)

Do you have a mental benchmark for this type of thing? Mine had pretty much been that I would never do better than about 2X (100% mark-up) on gold and it could be much higher if something were superbly made or engraved, etc. I am helped in this math by the gold run-up, which could head back down very soon. Again, I do not speculate in gold or jewelry and generally just buy simple, low-key things to enjoy.
 

Pomelo

Brilliant_Rock
Joined
Oct 20, 2015
Messages
543
Hehe I do indeed for the simplest pieces like chains and plain bands.

This cigar band was approx 1.2x the price of gold - it was a pawn shop find and on sale.

I haven’t bought a heavy gold chain though so not sure where my benchmark would be on that, but would think it’s around 20-50% depending on the craftsmanship.

IMG_7291.jpeg
 
Joined
Jan 20, 2012
Messages
4,242
"Hey, do you want fries with that?"

(Also: I know that an elephant for a quarter is only a good deal if you have a quarter and need an elephant.)

My sense of humor wants to have a beer with yours.
drinkingbuddies.gif


I would buy one or both in a heartbeat. Gold chains are versatile workhorses in any collection. European handmade (18k)? Substantial? Below retail? No-brainer in my book! And big congrats (to your dear daughter) on the ring!!
 

LilAlex

Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Mar 3, 2018
Messages
3,654
I would buy one or both in a heartbeat. Gold chains are versatile workhorses in any collection. European handmade (18k)? Substantial? Below retail? No-brainer in my book!

More enabling?! :lol-2: But these are kind of my thoughts, too.

(World's best) FIL was in sales and I always hear his voice in my head from when he'd poke fun at his own impulse purchases: "I can't afford not to buy it!"

Spouse is not in love with the tubogas (German, heavier, and the "better value" at only a 30% premium) -- she has an aversion to anything snake-like. And it's, well, pretty snake-like in person. But this one is really supple and fluid with an oval cross-section and just drapes over the collarbone. It has a one-inch linker chain in the back which does not look great in pictures, but looks integral and original and would make a nice sacrificial breakaway point if anyone were to snatch it on the subway, etc. I hate to think that way but, you know.

The link one (French; 50% premium over melt value) is not solid but feels almost like it could be; it does not feel like you could dent the links without a hammer. It has a cool spring-loaded horseshoe clasp with a cab garnet on the end, too.

Screen Shot 2024-04-09 at 10.35.09 PM.png
Screen Shot 2024-04-09 at 10.34.33 PM.png
 

smitcompton

Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Feb 11, 2006
Messages
3,272
Hi,

Well, you know what to expect from me now. This morning Bank of Ameria projected gold at 2500.00 by the fourth quarter.
I don't care for the snake one either.

I wish to be included in the beer meeting. Alex I still can laugh at your copy of the tiffany paper cup, Love your humor.

Annette
 

Daisys and Diamonds

Super_Ideal_Rock
Joined
Apr 30, 2019
Messages
22,814
More enabling?! :lol-2: But these are kind of my thoughts, too.

(World's best) FIL was in sales and I always hear his voice in my head from when he'd poke fun at his own impulse purchases: "I can't afford not to buy it!"

Spouse is not in love with the tubogas (German, heavier, and the "better value" at only a 30% premium) -- she has an aversion to anything snake-like. And it's, well, pretty snake-like in person. But this one is really supple and fluid with an oval cross-section and just drapes over the collarbone. It has a one-inch linker chain in the back which does not look great in pictures, but looks integral and original and would make a nice sacrificial breakaway point if anyone were to snatch it on the subway, etc. I hate to think that way but, you know.

The link one (French; 50% premium over melt value) is not solid but feels almost like it could be; it does not feel like you could dent the links without a hammer. It has a cool spring-loaded horseshoe clasp with a cab garnet on the end, too.

Screen Shot 2024-04-09 at 10.35.09 PM.png
Screen Shot 2024-04-09 at 10.34.33 PM.png

oh those are really really nice
i feel it is our job here to enable !

always feel a little ad when i hear someone doesn't like snakes- Prince Albert gave Queen Victoria a snake ER as the serpent represents eternal love

i watch these guys on you tube -initially because they had a pet alligator in their back room but they have a reptile center now


mind you easy for me to say as it is illegal to have a snake in NZ, even at a zoo,
 

LilAlex

Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Mar 3, 2018
Messages
3,654
This morning Bank of Ameria projected gold at 2500.00 by the fourth quarter.
I don't care for the snake one either.

I guess investment necklace it is! That the clear winner is the link chain is very helpful -- thank you! It's less of a "bargain," but maybe there's a reason. I'm hoping the link one has an identifiably French hallmark or maker's mark, etc.

I'd have to buy the link for sure (now that I know it has the added bonus of a "secret" garnet). The tubogas would still be a definite maybe from me

Another vote for the link! Yeah that little cab -- it's like the Cartier "sapphire" in the watch crown. It's doing a lot of heavy lifting -- it makes me think, "This must be well made!"

I love the link chain! Gorgeous! I think it's more timeless than the tubogas.

Appreciate the candor -- thank you. I guess I should have had a "vote" button!

always feel a little ad when i hear someone doesn't like snakes- Prince Albert gave Queen Victoria a snake ER as the serpent represents eternal love

I will reinforce that concept. I predict that historical reference and appeal to reason will turn her right around. :mrgreen2:

Damn, I love that link chain… I’m normally such a bargain hunter that I pay maybe 20 to 30% above melt...

And another!

She really does hate snakes. She was a kid in "snake country." And also "bear country." And a few other countries I can't remember right now. We'll be hiking and she will say "This...feels like [snake/bear/cougar/dinosaur] country" and it's like how you're home alone and your pet suddenly and with seemingly zero provocation gets hyper-alert...and it's just not a lot of fun after that.

I'll need to go back with her and see how (if) she likes it. Kind of a hard thing to say "no way" to.

I'll be sure to print this all out and bring it with me!
 

Mreader

Ideal_Rock
Joined
Aug 14, 2018
Messages
6,184
I guess investment necklace it is! That the clear winner is the link chain is very helpful -- thank you! It's less of a "bargain," but maybe there's a reason. I'm hoping the link one has an identifiably French hallmark or maker's mark, etc.



Another vote for the link! Yeah that little cab -- it's like the Cartier "sapphire" in the watch crown. It's doing a lot of heavy lifting -- it makes me think, "This must be well made!"



Appreciate the candor -- thank you. I guess I should have had a "vote" button!



I will reinforce that concept. I predict that historical reference and appeal to reason will turn her right around. :mrgreen2:



And another!

She really does hate snakes. She was a kid in "snake country." And also "bear country." And a few other countries I can't remember right now. We'll be hiking and she will say "This...feels like [snake/bear/cougar/dinosaur] country" and it's like how you're home alone and your pet suddenly and with seemingly zero provocation gets hyper-alert...and it's just not a lot of fun after that.

I'll need to go back with her and see how (if) she likes it. Kind of a hard thing to say "no way" to.

I'll be sure to print this all out and bring it with me!

I love snakes and snake jewelry (where it looks like an actual snake though). To me the other chain doesn’t have a snake association in that it doesn’t look like a literal snake to me! But I still prefer the link one. How heavy is it?? I just love heft in gold. I hate flimsy feeling chains and rings.
 

LilAlex

Ideal_Rock
Premium
Joined
Mar 3, 2018
Messages
3,654
How heavy is it?? I just love heft in gold. I hate flimsy feeling chains and rings.

Well, this is a little personal but I'll do almost anything to bump "Composting Humans" and "Punching Women" out of the top five for a few.:cool2:

The link one is about 55 g (maybe not a true heavyweight to some of you but it warranted an "Oh!" when I first picked it up) and the tubogas is about 95 g. So now you know how much I was prepared to "invest" on a random whim. In my defense, and unlike for any gem or jewelry purchase I have ever considered, these will be worth 65 - 75% of their purchase price the day after I buy. I'm accustomed to a much bigger downward reset. Although: there was a thread here or maybe on a financial forum that suggested people were struggling to get anywhere near spot price for scrap gold.

To be fair, neither one of them looks grotesquely look-at-me like those 1-kg curb-links on IG.
 

Mreader

Ideal_Rock
Joined
Aug 14, 2018
Messages
6,184
Well, this is a little personal but I'll do almost anything to bump "Composting Humans" and "Punching Women" out of the top five for a few.:cool2:

The link one is about 55 g (maybe not a true heavyweight to some of you but it warranted an "Oh!" when I first picked it up) and the tubogas is about 95 g. So now you know how much I was prepared to "invest" on a random whim. In my defense, and unlike for any gem or jewelry purchase I have ever considered, these will be worth 65 - 75% of their purchase price the day after I buy. I'm accustomed to a much bigger downward reset. Although: there was a thread here or maybe on a financial forum that suggested people were struggling to get anywhere near spot price for scrap gold.

To be fair, neither one of them looks grotesquely look-at-me like those 1-kg curb-links on IG.

Lol on bumping the threads out of the line. I realize my questions sounded like it was fishing for the price, but I forgot about that and was genuinely curious about the weight I promise! And yeah 55 g is definitely a chunky chain! I hope you got it.
 

Gloria27

Brilliant_Rock
Premium
Joined
Jul 21, 2015
Messages
984
Well, this is a little personal but I'll do almost anything to bump "Composting Humans" and "Punching Women" out of the top five for a few.:cool2:

The link one is about 55 g (maybe not a true heavyweight to some of you but it warranted an "Oh!" when I first picked it up) and the tubogas is about 95 g. So now you know how much I was prepared to "invest" on a random whim. In my defense, and unlike for any gem or jewelry purchase I have ever considered, these will be worth 65 - 75% of their purchase price the day after I buy. I'm accustomed to a much bigger downward reset. Although: there was a thread here or maybe on a financial forum that suggested people were struggling to get anywhere near spot price for scrap gold.

To be fair, neither one of them looks grotesquely look-at-me like those 1-kg curb-links on IG.

I'd get at least one. Sounds like a good deal and prices are only going up.
 
Be a part of the community Get 3 HCA Results
Top