HCA says "Dangerously Thin Girdle" -- is this true??

[Coop54]

Attached are the dimensions straight out of the GIA report, but when I plug them into the Holloway Cut Advisor it won't calculate a score because it says they were entered wrong or the stone has a "Dangerously Thin Girdle."

I've seen the stone in person and it looks great. I didn't specifically look at the girdle, but I don't recall it being a knife edge.

Any thoughts? Are these dimensions reason to avoid this stone?

 

[scarsmum]

You’ve entered a dimension wrong, probably depth. Result is excellent, 1.6.

 

[Tourmaline]

It's possible that you entered the crown and/or pavilion depth instead of angle.

 

[gm89uk]

Check your values, looks like nice stone

 

[diamondseeker2006]

Yep, nothing in those numbers would trigger a girdle warning.

 

[lalala]

61.7% = Depth
57% = Table
35 = Crown Angle
40.8 = Pavilion Angle

You may have put in a percent for the crown and pavilion angles. Double check the settings on the HCA tool. There is a drop down selection for the crown and pavilion. Make sure they are set to angle.