waxing lyrical
Shiny_Rock
- Joined
- Dec 29, 2008
- Messages
- 404
I'm not a parent, but I can understand how it would be hurtful if a child changed his or her name. At the same time, imagine how awful it would be to be stuck in a name that you hated. I have a friend who started out life as Amanda, changed to Mandy, then finally to Taylor. She (now he) ended up changing his last name a few years later, too.somethingshiny said:I know a man who changed his last name so he wouldn't be identified with his father.
I don't mean to offend, but I do think it's strange to change the name that was chosen by your parents. As a mom, I put a lot of thought into what names I gave my children. The names are meaningful to me for very specific reasons and if they changed it, I would be devastated.
Yssie said:I did know someone who changed her name from Abby to Abigail, and I understand her reasoning - Abby sounds like a nickname, and nicknames aren't always appropriate in some professions
somethingshiny said:I think using a middle name, changing based on culture or moving and of course transgender based changes are all perfectly fine.
To the OP, I completely understand wanting an adult name. This was one area of thought we considered greatly while choosing names. The names had to sound good for all walks of life and at all ages.
sillyberry said:I'm not a parent, but I can understand how it would be hurtful if a child changed his or her name. At the same time, imagine how awful it would be to be stuck in a name that you hated. I have a friend who started out life as Amanda, changed to Mandy, then finally to Taylor. She (now he) ended up changing his last name a few years later, too.somethingshiny said:I know a man who changed his last name so he wouldn't be identified with his father.
I don't mean to offend, but I do think it's strange to change the name that was chosen by your parents. As a mom, I put a lot of thought into what names I gave my children. The names are meaningful to me for very specific reasons and if they changed it, I would be devastated.
He ultimately didn't identify with the person her parents named. I think that's the case a lot of times where the name just doesn't fit, and the meaning you (universal you) feel might not have the same positive associations for the person actually bearing the name. If a name change can make the person feel better in his or her skin, I think that's ultimately a good thing.
And, also, some people hate their parents and want nothing to do with a name associated with them. But that's a whole nother ball of wax.
Yeah, I know for some names it shocks me that the people even keep the names. Seems like some last names are flat out cruel to go by and I can only imagine the kids/teenagers being tortured by all their classmates. lolSniven said:I had a professor that made her husband change his last name before she would take it, both in spelling and pronunciation.
His last name was Cok (male rooster) and he changed it to Coke (refreshing beverage).
She said she couldn't handle being called Mrs. Male Rooster all day every day.
somethingshiny said:I don't mean to offend, but I do think it's strange to change the name that was chosen by your parents. As a mom, I put a lot of thought into what names I gave my children. The names are meaningful to me for very specific reasons and if they changed it, I would be devastated.