Found EC - Need Some Input

[thegoat]

Found this EC....price is $12,295. I need some input for all the emerald mavens out there. Both are GIA. Thanks!

#1

$12,820

EC - 1.92
CUT: VG
COLOR: G
MEASUREMENTS: 8.01X5.90X4.25
RATIO: 1.36
DEPTH: 72%
TABLE: 61%
GIRDLE: SLTLY TK
CULET: NONE
POLISH: VG
SYMMETRY: VG
FLUOR: NONE
#2

$13,242

EC - 1.82
CUT: VG
COLOR: G
MEASUREMENTS: 8.11X6X4.1
RATION: 1.35
DEPTH: 68.3%
TABLE: 63%
GIRDLE: VTN-M
CULET: NONE
POLISH: VG
SYMMETRY: GOOD
FLUOR: NONE

 

[krisvrn]

Date: 2/29/2008 10:39:46 AM
Author:thegoat

Found this EC....price is $12,295. I need some input for all the emerald mavens out there. Both are GIA. Thanks!

#1

$12,820

EC - 1.92
CUT: VG
COLOR: G
MEASUREMENTS: 8.01X5.90X4.25
RATIO: 1.36
DEPTH: 72%
TABLE: 61%
GIRDLE: SLTLY TK
CULET: NONE
POLISH: VG
SYMMETRY: VG
FLUOR: NONE

#2

$13,242

EC - 1.82
CUT: VG
COLOR: G
MEASUREMENTS: 8.11X6X4.1
RATION: 1.35
DEPTH: 68.3%
TABLE: 63%
GIRDLE: VTN-M
CULET: NONE
POLISH: VG
SYMMETRY: GOOD
FLUOR: NONE

Stone 1 seems deep but have u seen it in person?

I''ve heard that table and crown for EC should be no more than 70% (and I believe that is high end)
I really think you need to see stones in person.

 

[chrono]

Stone #1
What is the clarity? What cert?
Stone is deep at 72%, so it'll look smaller than stone 2. Not sure if you really want to pay so much for a stone that looks smaller than it should.
Crown height?
Any pictures?



Stone #2
What is the clarity? What cert?
Depth a bit deep but can be forgiven if the crown height is good.
Crown height?
Concerned a little about the Very Thin girdle. Where is that part on the stone?
Would aim for at least VG on symmetry, otherwise the steps might not be even.
Need pictures.

 

[canuk-gal]

HI:

You probably are not looking for a three stone EC ring, but I had to post this beauty anyway......

http://www.signedpieces.com/item.cfm?item_id=7447

cheers--Sharon

 

[strmrdr]

neither stone is one I would consider for the reasons mentioned.