Found 2 cushions~ I need you expert opinons

[ma1lyc]

I found 2 stones... since i''m a newbie at this i am going to need your expertise in this

both stone have only a "good" symmetry... i know some ppl prefer very good- excellent. Also i can''t make out the numbers forthe table on the 2nd cushion but i hope the other information given would still be fine. the 2nd stone is 1k more than the frist one, maybe b.c of the higher color grade... i''m not sure which one i should get...
pls help
1. Cushion Modified Brilliant GIA

measurements: 6.83x6.37x4.31
weight: 1.70ct
depth: 67.7%
Table: 59%
Girdle: Thin to Extremely thick, faceted
Cutlet: none
polish: very good
symmetry: good
clarity grade: vvs2
color grade: G
Flor: non

2. Cushion Modified Brilliant GIA
measurements: 6.65x6.53x4.50
weight: 1.62ct
depth: 68.9%
Table: can''t make out the numbers*
Girdle: Thin to thick, faceted
Cutlet: none
polish: excellent
symmetry: good
clarity grade: VS1
color grade: F
Flor: non

 

[ma1lyc]

i forgot to ask

does anyone know what kinda cushion this would be more square / rectangle?

 

[Gothgrrl]

With a L/w ratio 1.00-1.06 would be pretty square.

 

[jaz464]

This will show you what the shape will kinda look like. There is no cushion to choose but the princess works for this.

http://www.gemappraisers.com/shapePickerNew.asp

 

[starburst]

i''d get the first one, it''s bigger, and clarity is better. it''s hard to tell the diff between an F and a G when mounted on wg or plat.

 

[jaz464]

Pictures would be very helpful. You certainly don't need VS1 or VVS2 unless you simply like the idea of a diamond with such high clarity. You are paying for something that will look no different from an eyeclean SI1 with the naked eye.

Definitely not liking the girdle on the first one.

 

[Cehrabehra]

Date: 3/14/2007 10:39:53 PM
Author: jazmine
This will show you what the shape will kinda look like. There is no cushion to choose but the princess works for this.

http://www.gemappraisers.com/shapePickerNew.asp

actually oval works best - just give it some bulge and it is a perfect cushion!!!