nutellaonbothsides
Rough_Rock
- Joined
- May 29, 2024
- Messages
- 5
Hi. I have heard good things about this community and so I decided to go ahead and register to ask for a second opinion.
For an engagement ring, I am looking for a diamond around 1ct (0.9 - 1.15).
My initial budget was 4-4.5k but I increased it a little to be able to target GREAT CUTS. I am OK to compromise a little bit on the other 2Cs (I, VS2).
I am looking at James Allen because this is the only site proposing the setting I want. After a first post where I received lots of feedback regarding importance of cut, I believe I found the best cut / brilliance I could find for my budget - actually slightly exceeding my budget.
This is the link to the diamond:
Why I am considering this one:
- Amongst other diamonds in the same price range, this seems to be the one with the cleanest ASET / least leakage - although I am still learning about how to spot them. I just see much less white spots for this one.
- The carat weight is spot on with my ideal find: Just a little over 1ct.
- No comment on the GIA report
- No visible inclusions on the zoomed preview.
Now for the red flags:
- Carat is higher than other diamonds with same search filters for that price range. Is diamond market efficient? If yes there is a catch.
- Potential haziness? I am paranoid about it because I can't really see it. Other people seems to though.
Could you please help me understand if there is something wrong with this diamond? It seems to good compared to the other ones for that price range.
For reference this is the link I am using to only display the diamonds I am potentially interested in: https://www.jamesallen.com/loose-di...rom=50.5&TableFrom=54&TableTo=56.5&Flour=None
(although I wonder if table size <56 isn't a bit restrictive)
Thanks in advance for your help
For an engagement ring, I am looking for a diamond around 1ct (0.9 - 1.15).
My initial budget was 4-4.5k but I increased it a little to be able to target GREAT CUTS. I am OK to compromise a little bit on the other 2Cs (I, VS2).
I am looking at James Allen because this is the only site proposing the setting I want. After a first post where I received lots of feedback regarding importance of cut, I believe I found the best cut / brilliance I could find for my budget - actually slightly exceeding my budget.
This is the link to the diamond:
Why I am considering this one:
- Amongst other diamonds in the same price range, this seems to be the one with the cleanest ASET / least leakage - although I am still learning about how to spot them. I just see much less white spots for this one.
- The carat weight is spot on with my ideal find: Just a little over 1ct.
- No comment on the GIA report
- No visible inclusions on the zoomed preview.
Now for the red flags:
- Carat is higher than other diamonds with same search filters for that price range. Is diamond market efficient? If yes there is a catch.
- Potential haziness? I am paranoid about it because I can't really see it. Other people seems to though.
Could you please help me understand if there is something wrong with this diamond? It seems to good compared to the other ones for that price range.
For reference this is the link I am using to only display the diamonds I am potentially interested in: https://www.jamesallen.com/loose-di...rom=50.5&TableFrom=54&TableTo=56.5&Flour=None
(although I wonder if table size <56 isn't a bit restrictive)
Thanks in advance for your help