Feedback On These Two Cushion Diamonds

[diamond_cluster]

This is my first official post and I'm trying to make a decision on one of these lovely cushion diamonds for my future fiancee. Initially I've always been drawn to old mine cushions and actually started wanting a Good Old Gold AVC but months have gone by and they have yet to restock their AVC diamonds. Of the diamonds listed below I'm really leaning towards the first ERD A Cut Beyond cushion but was worried about the slightly large cutlet specification. Should I be worried? I also like the other second diamond which is a completely different cut but would love some feedback of both. Any assistance would be greatly appreciated.

ERD A Cut Beyond Cushion
http://www.engagementringsdirect.com/index.php?file=diamond_details&gems_item_id=105725&first_step=diamond


ERD X Factor Cushion (this cut has really been growing on me)
http://www.engagementringsdirect.com/index.php?file=diamond_details&gems_item_id=81841&first_step=diamond

 

[diamond_cluster]

Looks like I've had several views but no one has chimed in with a response just yet. Any thoughts on the first diamond in terms of light performance judging from the ASET image or other specs? Thanks in advance.

 

[mogster]

The second one has been sold and so if you are a fatalist, all signs seem to point to the first cushion. The ASET of that one is on par with those of well-cut "generic" cushions.

 

[diamond_cluster]

Thanks much for the response mogster I really appreciate it and I didn't realize the second diamond was already sold. Folks seem to be moving fast these days with the holidays just around the corner. One last question though, I know I'm a novice and all but doesn't ERD's A Cut Beyond diamond qualify as a "antique" cushion versus a plain old "generic" cushion?

 

[mogster]

It is an antique-style cushion, just not branded like the AVCs and doesn't come with the AVC premium. Have you seen a diamond with a culet in person? It comes down to personal preference, but I've found that culets are hardly as pronounced as they are in (magnified) pictures.

 

[ecf8503]

The ERD cushion's culet is fine. It's not a huge window in the bottom of the stone... you'll barely notice it at all.

 

[CharmyPoo]

This is really up to you. The first diamond is an antique cut - big facets. The second diamond is a modern cut. Both are nice diamonds!

 

[diamond_cluster]

I can't say that I've actually seen a diamond with a culet in person. After seeing your response and doing some further research I don't think it's anything I should be worried about though. Thanks again for the feedback.

 

[diamond_cluster]

This is really up to you. The first diamond is an antique cut - big facets. The second diamond is a modern cut. Both are nice diamonds!

The big facets in the first diamond are exactly why I love the first diamond. Thanks for the feedback.

 

[Dougsgirl]

Personal preference, I MUCH prefer the "antique" style cushions, but that is probably why I bought an AVC.

Mine has a noticable culet in the GOG photo, but I don't notice it at all in person. Here is the GOG link to my diamond:
http://www.goodoldgold.com/diamond/9198/

I don't think a larger culet in that cut of a diamond is a big deal. It probably adds to the charm.

Here is a photo of my diamond in real life... (yet still magnified)


Good luck. I wouldn't worry about the culet if you love the cut.

 

[chel180]

i personally love open culets on both modern and antique cuts. they add a bit more charm imho. i know open culets are popular with all the ladies on her too so open or closed you should be safe.

 

[justginger]

I much prefer the look of antique-style cushions -- the ERD one you've linked to is beautiful. The ASET is good for an antique style stone, a mix of direct and indirect light source reflection. I would be very happy with that stone.

 

[Joolz]

I prefer the antique-style as well, but I'm biased as I have one! Mine also has a slightly large culet which is not nearly as obvious as it would seem. I really need to get closer to it to see it, it isn't noticeable at a casual glance. I really like the first stone, but what does your fiance prefer?

 

[diamond_cluster]

Personal preference, I MUCH prefer the "antique" style cushions, but that is probably why I bought an AVC.

Mine has a noticable culet in the GOG photo, but I don't notice it at all in person. Here is the GOG link to my diamond:
http://www.goodoldgold.com/diamond/9198/

I don't think a larger culet in that cut of a diamond is a big deal. It probably adds to the charm.

Here is a photo of my diamond in real life... (yet still magnified)


Good luck. I wouldn't worry about the culet if you love the cut.

Just simply beautiful (congrats)

 

[diamond_cluster]

I prefer the antique-style as well, but I'm biased as I have one! Mine also has a slightly large culet which is not nearly as obvious as it would seem. I really need to get closer to it to see it, it isn't noticeable at a casual glance. I really like the first stone, but what does your fiance prefer?

I haven't technically asked her, but I'm confident she wouldn't mind much either way. Plus my future fiance isn't really a diamond expert either. I feel good about this diamond though and its a good sign that my sister who got married 2 years back (and is more of a diamond connoisseur) mouth nearly hit the floor when I showed her the chunky faceted cushion I planned on buying for my future fiance .