Excellent cut?

[Jonbon11]

Hi, I am new to the forum and have been trying to narrow down my diamond selection I appreciate any help you may be able to provide. Would this diamond be considered excellent cut? Or is crown to small? I realize I cannot judge diamond solely on cut but curious as I have not seen dimensions like this before....

Table: 57 depth: 61.2 crown: 32.5 pavilion: 41

Carat 1.13 Measurement: 6.75x6.79x4.07

VVS1 I Colour


View media item 122223

 

[Jonbon11]

Would this be preferred over the above cut? they look very similar in online Images.... thank you in advance for any feedback.

Table: 57 depth: 61.1 crown: 34 pavilion 40.8

Carat: 1.07 measurement 6.57x6.62x4.03

Vs1 color i

 

[flyingpig]

The second stone with 34 crown is better.
A shallow stone (crown 32.5) looks actually good in online images with 8 well defined arrows, as you stated. But such stone may suffer in dispersion and fire in real life.

 

[Jonbon11]

The second stone with 34 crown is better.
A shallow stone (crown 32.5) looks actually good in online images with 8 well defined arrows, as you stated. But such stone may suffer in dispersion and fire in real life.

Thanks for the input, much appareciated. This is what I had assumed but was confused based off the excellent 0.7 HCA rating.

 

[OoohShiny]

The HCA is a tool to rule out stones quickly - the broadly accepted position is that as long as a stone is under 2.0 on the HCA, it is worth considering.

Most SuperIdeal AGS000 stones should fall within HCA<2.0, therefore you don't need to use it for branded stones such as White Flash A Cut Above, Brian Gavin Black, Crafted By Infinity sold by High Performance Diamonds...