Evaluate these two RBs please

[Ty Cobb]

3 RBs rather. All are for channel set rings. Each is from a different brand name B&M. Evaluate and rank them. I will reveal price and which brands when I check back later.


#1
6.15x 3.83 mm

size .89Ct
Color: H
Flour: none
Precision of cut : Ex
symmetry: ex
Polish: ex
clarity: VS1

Depth: 62.3
Table: 56
Crown height: 15
crown angle: 34.5
star length percent: 50
Pavillion depth: 43.4
Pav angle: 41.1
lower half percent: 80
Girdle: medium to slightly thick
finish: faceted
culet: none

#2
size 6.08-6.11 x 3.7
wt: .84 ct
color: f
fluor: none
Precision of cut : Ex
symmetry: VG
Polish: ex
clarity: VS1

Depth: 60.7
Table: 58
crown angle: 34.1
Pavillion depth: 43.4
Girdle: medium to slightly thick
finish: faceted
culet: none

#3
size 6.21-6.24x 3.8
wt: .91 ct
color: e
fluor: none
Precision of cut : Ex
symmetry: VG
Polish: ex
clarity: VS1

Depth: 60.0
Table: 58
crown angle: 35.4
Pavillion depth: 42.8
Girdle: medium to slightly thick
finish: faceted
culet: none


You can plug the numbers into HCA if you want, however I can do that tonight if I wish. I am merely inquiring to ya'lls impression of these numbers.

 

[kcoursolle]

Any particular reason you are picking VS1 clarity? An eye-clean SI will look the same as a VS1 to the naked eye. You can save money or go larger by dropping to at least VS2 or SI1. Also, you can drop in color to an H comfortably as well. Just a thought.

If you are set on VS1, I will evaluate the stones you picked.

 

[Ty Cobb]

Well, I am actually just making a comparison of stones at different high end retailers, and these 3 stones were the closest to each other that I found in their individual inventories. It is just a curiousity thing. Btw, the stones came from either T&CO, HW, or Cartier. It is mostly just for fun.

 

[ladykemma]

i would choose #3

 

[diamondseeker2006]

Well, I''ll just say that most of the stones bought from PS beat all three of these stones as far as the numbers go. I guess #1 looks the best to me other than being the lowest color of the three.

 

[ladykemma]

oop wrong thread
























Diamond Engagement Rings |Diamond Solitaire Rings |Custom Jewelry Design|Hearts and Arrows Diamonds
Princess Cut Diamonds | Diamond Education