Eternity band or engagement ring?

[Moiclaire]

I am debating between an eternity band or a diamond ring?
My concern with the eternity band would be the confort: here are the 2 models I am contemplating:

 

[motownmama]

Since comfort is a concern, have you tried these on,Claire? Is there a real life perspective pic of #1?

 

[Moiclaire]

You are right, and it is my concern. I would have the ring made so no way to try any of them!