Emerald Cut Stone Check Please

[JuJusJewels]

Hi all, please review these 3 emerald cut lab stones and give me a number 1(the best), 2, and 3 options for which you think will perform best. They are similar in price and would be so grateful for some input. It will be set in a Yellow Gold bezel if that helps. Thanks so much in advance.

3.97 H, VS1

Vision360 Viewer

3.85, G VS1

Media Links

3.69 H, VVS2

Gem360 - C3-1-A

ID: C3-1-A, Size: 3.69, Shape: Emerald, Color: H, Clarity: VVS2

view.gem360.in

 

[vintageinjune]

I feel the 3.97 looks the best to my eyes, then the 3.69, and I'd entirely rule out the 3.85 (but, only because the inclusions would drive me batty).

 

[JuJusJewels]

Thanks, that is what I was leaning toward, but have little experience with picking. Happy to get all the input I can

 

[momofive]

I'm not an expert, but I like the 3.97 and 3.69. I couldn't open the 3.85 for some reason.

 

[Karl_K]

3.85 has crystal issues, cut not horrible but not great.
3.69 has is the worst cut and has crystal issues.
The 3.97 has a bunch of small inclusions but they are spaced out and not dense which is a good thing.
It appears to dance well but face up needs better images or an in person look.

 

[JuJusJewels]

3.85 has crystal issues, cut not horrible but not great.
3.69 has is the worst cut and has crystal issues.
The 3.97 has a bunch of small inclusions but they are spaced out and not dense which is a good thing.
It appears to dance well but face up needs better images or an in person look.

Thanks so much for the assessment, Karl. Out of these two, which is better performing do you think? Thanks again.

3.97ct

Vision360 Viewer

OR

3.55 ct

Media Links

 

[Karl_K]

3.97
What are the numbers on it?

 

[JuJusJewels]

3.97
What are the numbers on it?

 

[JuJusJewels]

Table 66%, Depth 65.2%- is that what you mean?

 

[Karl_K]

Table 66%, Depth 65.2%- is that what you mean?

yes, numbers are ok.

 

[JuJusJewels]

yes, numbers are ok.

Other than the 3.55 color being better, do you think it’s inferior to the 3.97?