DOWN to 2 Stones Am I overlooking anything?

[dhk8880]

e=Stone:
2.31 Carats
AGS Ideal 0 Light Performance 0 Proportion Factors 0
Color H
Clarity VS2
Table 61.1
Depth 56
Crown 34.3
Pavaillion 40,7
HCA rates a 0.9
e=Stone:
2.43 Carats
GIA EX EX EX
Color H
Clarity VS2
Table 61.3
Depth 55
Crown 34.5
Pavaillion 40,8
HCA 1.2



I am buying one of these this weekend. I just need a little support. Ideal Scope are not available. I am leaning towards the 2.31 because it is the new AGS report.

Size wise you think there will be a difference?

Which stone would you choose?

Are AGS reports more accurate? Especially since this one has the Light reutrn?

Because these are well cut stones is there a chance when i get it it can be dud?

Thanks. Please help me choose!

 

[Skippy123]

The AGS, but if you get to see both in person I would choose the one that talks to you. You shouldn''t see too much of a difference in size. Yay for you!!!! How exciting!

 

[chrono]

I think you have the table and depth reversed: I doubt a stone with 56% depth and 61.1% table will get a AGS0 rating.

Sizewise, I doubt you'll see much difference.
As for duds, I recall a vendor saying he's never seen a AGS0 dud.

The 2 are really close; you can pick either one. Without an Idealscope pic, I'd play it safe and pick the AGS stone.

 

[aljdewey]

I''d most definitely choose the AGS stone, too. LUSCIOUS numbers, earned the light performance grade, wouldn''t be any appreciable difference size.......

Yep. I''d go with that one....the AGS.

 

[Ellen]

Date: 7/25/2007 3:26:32 PM
Author: aljdewey
I''d most definitely choose the AGS stone, too. LUSCIOUS numbers, earned the light performance grade, wouldn''t be any appreciable difference size.......

Yep. I''d go with that one....the AGS.

Ditto.

 

[dhk8880]

Thanks for you responses. I will be making my descision tommorow. I will post some pics when i get it in.

I am getting a custom band made kinda like a eternity ring with a mount. About 2.15 total weight.

Hopefully this stone looks good in it.

 

[Ellen]

Date: 7/25/2007 6:09:17 PM
Author: dhk8880
Thanks for you responses. I will be making my descision tommorow. I will post some pics when i get it in.

I am getting a custom band made kinda like a eternity ring with a mount. About 2.15 total weight.

Hopefully this stone looks good in it.

Sounds blingy and beautiful! I''m sure the stone will look great in it.

We look forward to the pics!

 

[kcoursolle]

Date: 7/25/2007 3:56:42 PM
Author: Ellen

Date: 7/25/2007 3:26:32 PM
Author: aljdewey
I''d most definitely choose the AGS stone, too. LUSCIOUS numbers, earned the light performance grade, wouldn''t be any appreciable difference size.......

Yep. I''d go with that one....the AGS.

Ditto.

double ditto.

I can''t wait to see the lovely ring when it''s done. You must come back with pictures, your setting sounds divine.

 

[dhk8880]

I pulled the trigger just bought the 2.31.

Should be here friday. unfortunatly band wont be completed for a couple weeks.

 

[Ellen]

Date: 7/25/2007 7:29:26 PM
Author: dhk8880
I pulled the trigger just bought the 2.31.

Should be here friday. unfortunatly band wont be completed for a couple weeks.

I can''t wait to see the completed ring. Please come back and post pics!!