Does this CH dress compete with the Ruffle dress?

[brightstone]

I found another Carolina H. Dress and am trying to decide whether I like the ruffles better or this one. Any thoughts or opinions that might help me decide? There is also one dress that I haven''t been able to try on yet. It''s the Melissa Sweet Katya....it''s almost a cross between the Ruffle dress and the Becca dress I tried before. I''ll post a pic of the model shot of that too. I am going to see if I can find it anywhere within 2-4 hours of me. It''s hard not living in the city anymore, where you have access to everything!

Also, thought I would post this link...this designer has some incredibly unique designs that are so fun - thought I would share. Unfortunately, there is no place near me that carries her. Enjoy! www.suzanne-ermann.com/

xo
Bright

 

[brightstone]

2

 

[neatfreak]

Which one are we comparing to? Can you post the picture again?

 

[brightstone]

3

 

[brightstone]

4

 

[brightstone]

ruffle1

 

[brightstone]

ruffle2

 

[brightstone]

ruffle3

 

[brightstone]

ruffle4

 

[brightstone]

Here are the dresses on the models

 

[brightstone]

It helps to see them at the right size, from these pics

 

[brightstone]

ruffle1

 

[brightstone]

ruffleback

 

[emeraldlover1]

Do you have the model pic of the other MS dress? I like the new CH dress too! I like the mermaid shape on you. I think maybe better than the ruff.

 

[brightstone]

Here is the model shot of the other dress I like that I haven''t tried but think is a cross between the ruffle dress and the becca dress

 

[bee*]

Out of the two dresses that you posted I prefer the Ruffle dress. I love that pic that you posted though of the other MS dress. I love the bottom of it.

 

[emeraldlover1]

i do like the new ms dress but I think you''d have to see it on as always. The bottom looks pretty similar on that do my ms dress which I absolutley love of course. I''m torn but I do like the new dress on you and the ruffle dress...

 

[iheartscience]

Definitely the ruffle dress!

 

[Deelight]

I much prefer the ruffle on you - hands down for me

 

[rockzilla]

Both are lovely, but I really prefer the ruffle dress. The new dress has that detailing on the bottom, but is plain on the top - to my ee it looks a little "bottom heavy". The ruffle dress on the other hand, is more balanced, and gives you more of an hourglass shape, in my opinion.

The third dress could be a contender as well, but I'd have to see it on you.

 

[KimberlyH]

They''re both beautiful, and I think the answer depends on what look you''re going for. The MS dress is very modern, sleek and elegant, the ruffle dress is more girly and romantic. They both look lovely on you, you have an amazing figure and I think the MS showcases it a bit better. It''s wonderful that you have two gorgeous dresses to choose from, as hard as it may be to choose.

 

[neatfreak]

The ruffle is my vote...but that last one you haven''t tried yet I bet might be a winner as well...

 

[October2008bride]

I tried not to read other people''s replies yet so I''d be unbiased

I think you should either go with the ruffle or the new MS dress (at least try it on). Not loving the newest one to the same extent.

 

[E B]

I''ll put in a (pre-) vote for the Becca/Ruffle hybrid. I think that will knock the others out of the park, so to speak.

 

[brightstone]

Thanks guys!! - I agree I think the ruffle is more special looking and feminine. ok, so I will make the trip to try on the last MS dress I posted, and post those when I return. Hoping I can get out of work early to do that one day this rather than spend another weekend day driving again.

 

[jstarfireb]

I LOVE the mermaid dress on you! IMHO, it blows the ruffle dress way out of the water. But I never liked the ruffle dress to begin with. You WEAR that mermaid dress, but the ruffle dress is wearing you, so to speak. I still prefer the Becca out of all of these. The Melissa Sweet dress would be interesting to see on you as well.

 

[DMBsGirl]

I love the Melissa Sweet dress that you haven''t tried on yet! I think that would look gorgeous on you!!!

 

[indecisive]

I am still totally voting for the Becca... still no contest to me!

 

[AmberGretchen]

I like the ruffle dress and the last one that you haven''t been able to try on -I just think they both would show off your lovely figure so much better.

 

[lala2332]

I''m still voting ruffle....the mermaid is so different than everything else you''ve liked. I''m guessing that maybe it isn''t 100% your style, since mermaid style is just now coming into the equation.

THat being said, I remember that you really liked becca....the untried one may be the perfect solution.

YOu have a great figure so they are all going to look lovely on you. Go with the one you dream about!