charliethemutt
Rough_Rock
- Joined
- Jan 2, 2021
- Messages
- 5
Hello PS Community,
I'm new to the jewelry world I would love some some guidance on a round brilliant cut lab grown diamond for engagement ring. This stone will go into a hand forged white gold or yellow gold delicate antique style bezel setting.
I've looked at a handful of stones that my jeweler has brought in and identified one stone that I could use a second opinion on. I trust my jeweler with 30+ years of experience, which has noted it's a beautiful stone, but I hold some reservations due to the lab's grading reputation (IGI Antwerp), my lack of diamond expertise, and only viewing the stone through a jewelers loop (no microscope, no ideal scope, no ASET available at his shop). I am very focused on the cut and less concerned with the color and clarity (as long as it looks good within the final ring). Below are the diamond details.
Carat: 1.73
Color: i (in person, the stone looks really nice/symmetric, throws off great dispersion and scintillation, and pretty good brilliance, however, it's a little darker/looks deeper than others)
Clarity: VS2 (eye clean - a small inclusion on the perimeter of the stone)
Table: 56.6%
Depth: 61.6%
Crown Height/ Angle: 15% / 34.8 deg
Pavilion Depth / Angle: 43% /40.6 deg
Girdle: Medium
Fluorescence: none
Culet: Pointed
Polish & Symmetry: Excellent
Holloway Cut Advisor Score: 0.8
Should I trust these diamond cut metrics from IGI Antwerp? How much tolerance on the cut can these numbers be off to still produce an outstanding/super ideal cut? Ultimately, are there any reasons I should/should not purchase this (it's within my budget). I don't have an image or video at the moment.
Are there any shops like Brian Gavin or WF quality cuts for lab grade stones? I've looked at a number of online platforms and have been relatively disappointed with their clamed super ideal cut/heart & arrows. Please pass along any recommended super ideal cut round lab stones (around 1.75ct) that might fit what I'm looking for.
Really appreciate the help!!!
I'm new to the jewelry world I would love some some guidance on a round brilliant cut lab grown diamond for engagement ring. This stone will go into a hand forged white gold or yellow gold delicate antique style bezel setting.
I've looked at a handful of stones that my jeweler has brought in and identified one stone that I could use a second opinion on. I trust my jeweler with 30+ years of experience, which has noted it's a beautiful stone, but I hold some reservations due to the lab's grading reputation (IGI Antwerp), my lack of diamond expertise, and only viewing the stone through a jewelers loop (no microscope, no ideal scope, no ASET available at his shop). I am very focused on the cut and less concerned with the color and clarity (as long as it looks good within the final ring). Below are the diamond details.
Carat: 1.73
Color: i (in person, the stone looks really nice/symmetric, throws off great dispersion and scintillation, and pretty good brilliance, however, it's a little darker/looks deeper than others)
Clarity: VS2 (eye clean - a small inclusion on the perimeter of the stone)
Table: 56.6%
Depth: 61.6%
Crown Height/ Angle: 15% / 34.8 deg
Pavilion Depth / Angle: 43% /40.6 deg
Girdle: Medium
Fluorescence: none
Culet: Pointed
Polish & Symmetry: Excellent
Holloway Cut Advisor Score: 0.8
Should I trust these diamond cut metrics from IGI Antwerp? How much tolerance on the cut can these numbers be off to still produce an outstanding/super ideal cut? Ultimately, are there any reasons I should/should not purchase this (it's within my budget). I don't have an image or video at the moment.
Are there any shops like Brian Gavin or WF quality cuts for lab grade stones? I've looked at a number of online platforms and have been relatively disappointed with their clamed super ideal cut/heart & arrows. Please pass along any recommended super ideal cut round lab stones (around 1.75ct) that might fit what I'm looking for.
Really appreciate the help!!!
Last edited: